Shoes to Wear With a Tinker Bell Costume

So what shoes to wear with a Tinkerbell costume? Well, it depends on three factors: what kind of fairy you are trying to be, where you are wearing your costume and where you live.

What Kind of Fairy?
Actually, I guess this question is more of a "how sexy" one than kind of fairy. Because a sexy fairy might go barefoot, but she isn't going to be caught dead in sneakers.

Where Wearing?
This is really a practical consideration because you don't want to be wearing stilettos if you're taking the kids trick-or-treating. So if you're going to be walking with the kids, sneakers or flats are called for. Just hanging at a party, flats or sandals or flip flops are perfect. Taking that costume dancing? Check out the uber hip and high options.

Where Live?
Let's face it. You can get away with flip flops for Halloween in Florida. Not so much in Minnesota. So there's a practical aspect to the whole shoe thing. And %u2026 there' not really a way to wear Tinker Bell-appropriate shoes out in the cold. Sigh.

One argument for not going with costume-y shoes is that you can wear them other times. Strappy silver sandals are great for going out at night and sneakers are practical anytime. When weighing between different styles, think about whether you could purchase something you could wear year-round. You could even move toward a silver or brown color instead of green to make that more possible.

Note that I have chosen these shoes based solely on looks. We're trying to complete a look here, so that was all that mattered to me. They vary greatly in terms of comfort, quality and cost, so shop smartly.

The first pair are the official licensed from Disney adult sized Tinker Bell shoes. That's the exact look, if that's important to you. The second pair is really close for a regular pair of shoes.

Tinker Ballet Flats Adult
$34.99 at Costumes Express


Mojo Moxy Women's Squiggle Flat

Ballet flats are the "normal" shoe that looks the most like Tinker Bell's from the Disney drawings. You can just wear them as they come or add a white or yellow pom pom to the toe area to make them match perfectly.

Blake Brody Women's Erin Small Bow Ballerina Flat


Miz Mooz Women's Dallas Ballet Flat


nicole Women's Glowing Flat


VANELi Womens Dastar Dress Flat


Rockport Women's Faye Petals Ballet Flat

Dr. Scholl's Women's Fiz Flat


Biviel Women's BV3091 Basic Pump


Funtasma By Pleaser Women's Star-16G Flat


Cleatskins V 1.5 Premier - Kelly Green

Other than sneakers, think light for your feet. That means no really large clunky shoes or dark colors unless it's a barely there shoe. Tinkerbell has to be able to fly, after all. So when you're looking, avoid anything that will weigh you down. (This is a practical fashion consideration as well since Tink's outfit is on the skimpy side.) This makes flip flops and casual sandals a good option if comfort is a goal.

Joseph Griffin Machada Flat Sandal


crocs Unisex Crocband Flip Flop


BCBGeneration Gilda Flip Flop Sandal


Nina Women's Hilaria-YS Wedge Sandal


Hush Puppies Women's Limon Thong Sandal

Nomad Glitzy (Women's) - Olive Rubber


Annie Shoes Women's Tatum Thong Sandal


Keen Women's La Paz Thong


Annie Shoes Women's Raffi Thong Mule


Cole Haan Women's Air Tali Flat Thong Sandal

Ivy Shoes
(Now those are some fairy shoes!)


J.Renee Women's Spruce Thong Sandal


Samanta Women's Anna T-Strap Flat


A. Marinelli Women's Digit Wedge Sandal


Two Lips Women's Tango Slingback Sandal


A. Marinelli Women's Regal Ankle-Strap Sandal

FRYE Women's Laurel Flower T-Strap Sandal


FRYE Women's Alessia Artisanal T-Strap Sandal


Mariana by GOLC Women's Tasha Sandal


Caparros Women's Zodiac Platform Sandal

Sneakers are a great option for walking and there are so many green choices! You can just let white shoelaces serve as your "pom pom" or add one to the toe of the shoe. And there are even some styles that look more like ballet flats and thus Tinker Bell's actual shoes.

Simple Hola SIIp-On Fashion Sneaker


Keen Women's Toyah Mary Jane Casual Shoe


Patagonia Footwear Tsali Trail Running Shoe


Puma Women's EL Ace Fashion Sneaker


Salomon Women's Smoothie Walking Shoe


crocs Women's Melbourne II Lace-Up Shoe

Gola Marvel Slip-On


Bensimon Women's Ballerine Flo Lace-Up Fashion Sneaker


C1RCA Women's 50 Classic Sneaker


PUMA Archive NM Fashion Sneaker


Puma EL Rey Nylon Fashion Sneaker

Some of these are a little heavy, but if you want some height and sexy, they're good options.

Bordello by Pleaser Women's Violette-12G Sandal


Chocolate Negro Women's 50586 Ankle-Strap Sandal


Bordello Teeze Green Glitter

rsvp Ramona


Butter Women's Salute Platform Twist Sandal


Bandolino Women's Poise T-Strap Sandal

Now - boots aren't exactly Tinker Bell style. But for practical considerations, you might need or want to consider them. You could pair them with green tights under your costume to help you stay warm. That will move you to looking a little like Peter Pan on the bottom half, so make sure you really glam up the top to be very clearly Tink.

Aerosoles Women's Sota Fountain Boot


Kathy Van Zeeland Women's Julian Bootie


LifeStride Women's Yalta Boot

Nine West Women's Timeoff Boot


RJ Girl Women's Alle Open-Toe Ankle Boot


Eject Women's 12334 Ankle Boot

Some of these are really big and clunky, but the light silver color and clear soles balance that out. If you're looking for a sexy shoe to go with your Tinker Bell costume, these are the way to go for sure.

Johnathan Kayne Charleston


Special Occasions Diva Silver


Special Occasions Palace


Lava Shoes Star

Dyeables Striking


Dyeables Emory


Special Occasions Alyssa


Lava Shoes Taboo