Debate: Did Steve Irwin deserve to die?

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 1 person | Log in to rate

Ranked #4,949 in Animals, #113,250 overall

HERE'S WHAT I THINK


Steve Irwin, the Crocodile Hunter, risked his life many times in close contact with dangerous animals. Many feel he was a gift to wildlife, an entertainer, an inspiring risk-taker and funny to watch.

There are others who contend that the freak attack which claimed his life was due to his disrespect for the unpredictability of wild creatures, avoidable and ultimately his own fault.

Where do you stand?

YOUR TURN! 

Did Steve Irwin deserve to die?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

He knew the risks, and took them anyway. For money, for glory, for whatever -- he left his children fatherless.

debs says:

No one deserves to die, but he pushed his limits,and we all could see it coming - be honest!!!
I know a fair bit about adhd, and he certainly fit that description. If you read the book that terri wrote, she tells how he was vidoeing her, while driving to the hospital when she was in labour. She told him to put the video down, but no luck. She clearly lived her life, to go along with whatever he did or said. She still is. He was very controlling and set in his ways. He was an adrenilin junky, with an undiagnosed adhd, but a wonderful person indeed. He is missed dearly.

berty says:

yes he did, theres a difference between taking an interest in animals and scaring the shit out of them,
wild animals are wild for a reson, let them beg

berty says:

if he cared so much about animals why did he always scare and upset them by scaring them and try to pick them up?

steve says:

yes he deserve to die. Its his fault for harassing the animals by touching them making them feel uneasy. it aint the stingrays fault for steve irwins stupidity by taunting and grabbing it. Its natural for stingrays to feel scared cause of that

Inspired says:

No,he desrved to live and carry on protecting wildlifes. Why these great people whereas the ones to die are animal hunters,traders,smugglers,worthless smugglers,terroist, country deterioter,those fuckers. He was a true inspirer and a great person that gave people the understanding of protecting wildlifes.May he rest in peace,thanks for your deeds!

lowrisksteve says:

So many people were surprised by Steve's "untimely" death & his friends claimed that his fatal attack was unprovoked. Yeah, right! Did you ever see this guy when he wasn't antagonizing a deadly animal?... ("I'm in complete control mate!")... Not only did he continuously put himself in harms way, but also was starting to put other (innocent) people in harms way as well (his own infant son. Remember that?). His death seemed to me to be anything other than "untimely", and quite possibly a blessing to others. I'm glad that no children had to witness his "untimely" demise.

They don't call them "freak accidents" for nothing -- you're more likely to die in your bathtub than by a stingray.

bob says:

steve is a great man bercause i am doing a biograghy on steve

J. Layne says:

NO ONE deserves to die.
he's just like any other human who is involved in a carrer with animals. they are unpredictable and he understood that. Think of jockeys. Don't they risk their life everytime they get on a horse? Or Olympic eventers who jump horses over 5ft obstacles? Wildlife veternarians? These people all have families at home. Come on people think about it. Things go wrong sometimes. Such as in Christopher Reeves situation, a horse spooked at a 3ft fence (usually an easy obstacle to clear). Steve Irwin was one the the many people since i was young to inspire me to pursue a carrer to help animals. To critize him over his death is the most disrespectful thing you could do to this man. To hear he left his children fatherless, what kind of comment is that? So a policeman dieing on duty, is an honored death, even though he might have left his children fatherless? But, Steven Irwin continuing his passion for wildlife was wortheless, even if in fact, that his daughter is now only walking in his footsteps? Consider the children, would they want you to say these things about there father?

Beanie says:

Nobody deserves to die!!! He was a risk taker but that doesnt mean he deserves to die!!!

Mar says:

Steve Irwin DID NOT deserve to die. what happened to him was a freak accident that not even he could see coming. He knew how to handle himself around animals and what happened to him just happened its not because he was being stupid or dangerous. All I can say now is that we lost a Great Hero you will be missed Steve

m says:

He did now deserve to die

Rheanna says:

nobody deserves to die Steve was doing what he Enjoyed most living &playing with animals he DID NOT DESERVE TO DIE he was a very respectful man i love him he was a very special person to me he was my hero & my Role Model if he was here i would be so happy now he i s a s in a better place

sharon says:

NO!!! i dont believe that anyone "deserves" to die!! and the people that said yes...i feel BAD for them....how can u feel that way about anyone.....that is JUST horrible!!!! Steve Irwin did more in his life for this PLANET then anyone or anything....we all should respect him....whether are not we were fans of his!!!

jack bruce jones says:

no

courtney says:

he didnt deserve 2 die, i guess every body dies. he was so young and lots of kids would want 2 be just like him

Hill says:

lowrisksteve your an idiot. first of all his son was never in any real danger and all the charges were dropped. and second how and why would anyone want to provoke a stingray? you thibk steve starting ticking it belly or something? no he was swimming over it.

Bruin says:

Steve Irwin has always said if anything goes wrong it's his own fault. So sure maybe some can say it's his fault but he doesn't deserve to die. He did nothing but help animals and help preserve land. he even donated a million dollars a year to charity. why would anyone say he deserved to die? who would put Steve Irwin with the ranks of Hitler?

dc64 says:

I loved Steve Irwin, he had a delightful way of introducing us to his love of animals. I haven't watched any of his shows since his death. It just makes me sad. We all take risks in live, that shouldn't stop us from enjoying the time we have on Earth.

V.I. says:

Steve Irwin death was unfortunate; however, as freeleif said, it was just his time to go. I personally enjoyed his shows. Steve died doing exactly what he loved and he probably wouldn't change a thing about what he did. He lived his life to fullest, while educating the world about the importance of wild life to nature's balance. Thank you Steve.

TopStyleTravel says:

Steve Irwin made a mistake that cost his life. He did not deserve to die. His reality since childhood was being closer to animals than most would care to be. We all makes choices in life, some are more adventurous than others. But we all should respect the life we have and take precautions. Because it is not always the other guy, it could be you or me to die.

freelief says:

While I want to be here for my own children, I don't live life in a protected bubble. Life is full of calculated risks. It was his time; could have been a car crash instead, but once your number is up, no running from it. RIP.

 

Tributes 

YouTube thumbnail
steve irwin tribute

Runtime: 3:38 | 358575 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Steve Irwin -by Bindi

Runtime: 1:33 | 621478 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Steve Irwin Tribute

Runtime: 4:34 | 24720 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Steve Irwin Tribute - You will...

Runtime: 4:05 | 202667 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Steve Irwin tribute

Runtime: 2:39 | 31763 views | Comments

YouTube thumbnail
Steve Irwin Tribute by Regis a...

Runtime: 4:05 | 21538 views | Comments

automatically generated by YouTube"

The OMG-teh-best-evar Steve Irwin Video 

YouTube has pulled the plug on it, but you can still find it if you're resourceful.

Crocodile Hunter Steve Irwin meets his match in Jay Leno's Tonight Show intern Ross: LARGE - MEDIUM - SMALL

Six minutes of genius.

DEBATE SOME MORE 

 

Cool stuff you can do with this page:









You like me, you really like me!







Finally, please rate this lens (top of the page):

by XP

XP is a self-proclaimed Squid Princess, an official Giant Squid and new Squid Angel. She digs the outdoors, her amazing family, critters both wild and... (more)

Explore related pages

Create a Lens!