Strawberry Jam vs Grape Jelly: You Decide!

Ranked #8,742 in Food & Cooking, #157,981 overall

Is it Preference or Popularity?

The taste of a Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich brings back memories of childhood. But the debate has always been one of which jelly does a true PB&J make? Is it Strawberry Jam or Grape Jelly? Join the debate, cast your vote and make your voice heard! Which will win? You decide!

What is a Sandwich?

From humble beginnings to easy convenience.

While bread and meat have gone together almost since the dawn of time, it wasn't until the 17th century that the idea of a "sandwich", placing meat between thin slices of bread that have been spread with butter, was observed.

The term 'sandwich' is ascribed to Edward Gibbon who wrote about the creation of John Montagu, 4th Earl of Sandwich, in his journal. An order of meat tucked between bread so it could be held while the Earl of Sandwich was playing cards caught on in popularity among others of the 18th century aristocracy.

Since then the creation of hundreds of different types of sandwiches has happened; some based on local delicacies while others are internationally known. One of the most popular and well known is the Peanut Butter and Jelly. A sandwich that has filled the lunch boxes of school children for decades and has been a kind of "comfort" food for adults.

Commonly, a PB&J as it's known, consists of two pieces of bread, one slice spread with peanut butter, the other with a fruit preserve. The great debate has always been what type of jam or jelly makes a "true" (or best) PB&J.

Here's where you, dear reader, decide which is better: Strawberry Jam or Grape Jelly?

How to make a PB&J sandwich

(The hard way!)

Loading

Strawberry Jam vs Jelly!

Which Side Are You On?

Which is the only way to make a true PB&J?

Loading

With Strawberry Jam!

Mike says:

polaner strawberry jam

emmalarkins says:

This one's easy! I've always loved strawberries.

Sidther says:

I prefer the texture of the jam to jelly, I really like raspberry the best though!

ColleenLudgate says:

I've always been a strawberry jam fan...I've tried many different kinds, grape included, but always return to my old friend, the strawberry

Irenemaria says:

I have never heard of Grape jelly. But strawberry Jam I love

SereneSea says:

I love strawberry flavour, anything to do with strawberry.

Rajays says:

I love strawberries in any form. Strawberry jam for me please!

With Grape Jelly!

Trisha says:

I love strawberries, but I hate jam. It has a gross crunchy texture. The grape taste and the jelly texture make for a much better pbj.

_Joan_ says:

I'm biased because I'm allergic to strawberries, so grape jelly gets my vote. But the debate I'm more interested is whole wheat bread vs. white.

 

Peanut, Peanut Butter and Jelly!

Song about how to make a PB&J Sandwich
by apuleuis | video info

149 ratings | 157,284 views
curated content from YouTube

With Crusts or Without Crusts?

BONUS ROUND!

Which Do You Prefer?

Loading

A PB&J WITH crusts!

ColleenLudgate says:

I love the texture of the crust

blue22d says:

I think the crusts are some of the best parts of a slide of bread.

A PB&J WITHOUT crusts!

Sidther says:

Without! I don't like the texture!

 

Anything To Add?

Want to champion Strawberry Jam? Think Grape Jelly is better? Have a different opinion of what jam or jelly to use? Leave a comment and let us know!

  • jackiebolen Mar 7, 2011 @ 9:19 pm | delete
    Strawberry for sure, grape jelly is gross!
  • TapIn2U Feb 17, 2011 @ 12:41 pm | delete
    Strawberry jam - hands down! I just love love love it ever since I was a tiny little 6-year-old. :)

About the Lensmaster

Loading

More Yummy Lenses!

Loading

by

missbat

I'm a Giant 100 Squid, as well as a retired SquidAngel. I'm most known for my Halloween costume lenses. I also like to poke people with sporks.

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!