Ten Most Popular Homemade Cookie Flavors

Ranked #2,108 in Food & Cooking, #40,559 overall | Donates to CAER Food Shelf

Get to Know Your Cookies

Cookies are America's favorite leisure time snack. There are hundreds of choices on the supermarket shelves for the cookie lover to choose from. But nothing can compare to the flavors and textures of homemade cookies. From the thousands of cookie recipes out there, here are the ten most popular homemade cookie favors.

Image courtesy of SashaW on Flickr.

Items You Might Need

To Make These On Your Own

Loading

1. Chocolate Chip

Everyone's Favorite Cookie

Image by SMercury98 on Flickr

This delicious, buttery and oh-so-sweet cookie is the most popular for a good reason. Its melt in your mouth goodness has just the right amount of chocolate and cookie.

Whether frozen or warm, soft or crisp baked, chocolate chip cookies will forever reign as the perfect cookie for all ages. Not to mention, easy to make for all ages as well.

Kids love 'em

Image by whiteafrican on Flickr

Making Chocolate Chip Cookies

Learn from the professionals

Best Chocolate Chip Cookies
by tcoyle722 | video info

96 ratings | 110,953 views
curated content from YouTube

2. Peanut Butter

Tasty & Different

Image courtesy of Maggie Hoffman on Creative Commons

Some people love the peanut butter cookie, and some can do without it. But its fan base has kept it going throughout all the years of happy baking. Perhaps it's the criss-crossed fork marks on top that leave an indelible stamp in our minds or just that they look great in gift baskets. But the peanut yumminess is a classic American taste.

3. Oatmeal Raisin

Delicious & Good For You

Photo courtesy of Jugglerpm on Flickr

When it comes to the general consensus, I've found that you either love the oatmeal raisin, or you hate it. For the oatmeal raisin lover, this cookie brings joy with its delicious oat texture and chewy raisins.

Some home bakers even add nuts to the mix making it a delightful combination of tastes and a delightful little treat to the unsuspecting.

Making Oatmeal Raisin Cookies

Because they're good.

How To Make Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
by Howcast | video info

148 ratings | 37,765 views
curated content from YouTube

4. Sugar

Image by sinksanctity on Flickr

The sugar cookie still endures after all these years because of its sweet simplicity. Everyone loves rolled out sugar cookies spread with thick, colorful frosting and sprinkles.

The sheer versatility of this cookie makes it a blank canvas for home bakers to create masterpieces on. Frosting, sprinkles and food coloring are certainly optional, however.

5. White Chocolate Macadamia Nut

Cookie-Say-What?

Image by Andie712b on Flickr

For some, the macadamia nut is the ultimate in luxury and often times spotted in Christmas gift baskets.

Add white chocolate to it and you've got a delicacy of a cookie that is far from the everyday ordinary snack. Those who love it pine for its chunks of nuttiness.

Making White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies: Cookie Jar #13
by harwoodpodcast | video info

64 ratings | 12,230 views
curated content from YouTube

6. Chocolate Sandwich

Popular For a Reason

Image by istolethetv on Flickr

The chocolate sandwich cookie is the poor man's Oreo. No one can replicate the taste of the original Oreo, but home cooks have certainly come close.

With homemade cream filling, this sandwich cookie is a year round favorite for many households.

7. Coconut Macaroon

Living on the Edge

Image by norwichnuts on Flickr

Because there's no baking involved, these gourmet cookies almost seem like magic when they're made.

Coconut lovers around the world now have an exotic cookie to call their own. It spans generations as a sweet treat that's light and oh so edible.

Oh and did I mention that there's no baking involved?

Making Coconut Macaroons

Coconut Macaroons
by LiaisonCollege | video info

70 ratings | 45,746 views
curated content from YouTube

8. Shortbread

Perfect for Whenever

Photo by flavouredechoes on Flickr

Whenever shortbread comes out, you'll find that hands from all over come grabbing. It's simple but just so right for tea time.

Even lovers of more complicated cookies fall for the pure golden delight of a shortbread square. And what's not to love about shortbread? It tastes great with anything.

9. Gingerbread

Not the Houses

Image by dichohecho on Flickr

Is it that it comes out once a year that makes the homemade gingerbread cookie so fascinating? Maybe it's the shape or the decorations.

Whatever the reason, the gingerbread man and woman live on as symbols of holiday cookies and good cheer. Not to mention, they're worth waiting for.

Making Gingerbread Cookies

Hot out of the oven

How-to make Gingerbread Cookies
by holidaykitchen | video info

140 ratings | 81,447 views
curated content from YouTube

10. Animal Cookies

Open Up and Say "Roar"

Image by betsyweber on Flickr

Those daring bakers who take on the task of baking animal cookies have the hearts of children throughout the neighborhood. And then some adults as well.

Who can say no to a crisp baked circus animal freshly cut from dough so lovingly prepared?

Add Some Variation

Switch It Up A Bit

Image courtesy of Duchamp on Creative CommonsIf you're getting started on your cookie baking hobby, try these flavors first. There are so many variations you can add to make them uniquely yours. Add nuts or dried fruits. Try different shapes and frostings. Bake for a shorter or a longer time. Pair them with jams and jellies. Your cookies are your own palate to create tiny masterpieces that will quickly be gobbled up by eagerly awaiting mouths.

Take the Poll

Loading poll. Please Wait...

More Cookie Links

Easy Christmas Cookie Baking Tips
Baking and eating Christmas cookies are some of the greatest moments of the holiday season. Cookies that have been absent for a year suddenly return to the table. Our friends share their favorite recipes with...
Does Cookie Dough Fundraising Work?
Mention the word "cookie," and people come running.
America is in love with everything having to do with cookies. So, why not cash
in on that love and host a cookie dough fundraising event? Cookie dough...
Edible Alternatives To Sending Flowers
As an avid gardener, I have sent my share of flower bouquets to friends and family as gifts to say thank you or get well. However I've recently found some great alternatives to flowers that are just as...
Affordable Christmas Gifts: Homebaked Cookie Baskets or Tins
Sometimes it's little things that make difference during holiday season. And now, you can make your own cookies and make them look like you spent so much more! Affordable Christmas Gifts: Homebaked Cookie Baskets or Tins.
The Tradition of Baking Christmas Cookies
Sure, we all welcome tradition of baking cookies around Christmas time. But where did tradition come from and why do we do it? The Tradition of Baking Christmas Cookies.

Featured Lenses

Loading

Comments?

Yes, Please!

submit

About Me

Loading

by

DessertLover

I am an expert on all things sweet - baking, designing, and especially eating desserts! I'll be sharing my baking tips, recipes and favorite desserts.

I...
more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!