Those Who Can, Do, and Those Who Can't, Teach?!
Ranked #4,642 in Education, #106,059 overall | Donates to Acumen Fund
Devaluation of Teaching Profession - Not an Option! Either for Teachers or Parents!
Those Who Can, Do, and Those Who Can't, Teach?!
I don't have the slightest idea who came up with this idea, but somehow it turned into one of those cliches you hear on daily basis. And one of those which devalues teaching as a profession.
In the meantime, those who use this cliche conveniently forget one simple truth: If you showed any interest whatsoever during your school years, teachers were the ones who pushed you to see your limits and possiblities.
Teachers are the ones who helped you become the person you are today!
Image source: Male Teacher Sweatshirt by stick_figures
What Exactly Teachers Do?
Please, take a look at this video clip before moving down the page!
Taylor Mali is today a professional poet but he used to be a teacher himself.After being asked by a lawyer for an honest answer to the question, "You're a teacher Taylor--what do you make?" (aka earn), he decided to write a poem about the roles and responsibilities of teachers.
Taylor Mali is currently on a mission to create 1,000 new teachers through poetry, persuasion, and perseverance. So far, he's got 372.
What's Your Opinion on This Matter?
Agree or disagree when you hear the sentence:
Those Who Can, Do, and Those Who Can't, Teach?!
Fetching blurbs now... please stand byYes, that's 100% true!
Brian says:
I think it's mostly true at the university level. At the gradeschool level there are plenty who really did always want to teach. Take it from someone who regrets spending so much of his life in school. It really was a mistake.
Posted November 18, 2011
James says:
As a teacher who has recently entered the profession from another field, I don't want to agree with this little zinger, but if there's one realization I have come to about the profession as a whole in the past two years, it's that there are some astoundingly unqualified people in charge of classrooms full of children all over this country.
Posted November 11, 2011
tandemonimom says:
Yes and no. I have a degree in elementary ed, and in my classes there were many dedicated people who were driven to teach and help children, but sadly, there were just as many there because it was an easy course of study and they would get summers off. Yes and no.
Posted March 17, 2011
nickupton says:
I have worked with more bad teachers than good ones. I would have considered myself a good teacher, but now I do.
However, knowing your subject is one thing, but teaching it is another.
Posted November 02, 2009
mysticmama says:
I think that it really depends on a couple of factors as well as the subject matter... In my experience, I've met 2 types of teachers... those who became teachers from a genuine love of helping young minds grow & learn...These types of teachers are typically found in grammar schools & special education programs... Once we get to high schools & colleges...we begin to see a more and more teachers, as the stident body gets older, who are the type of teachers & professors who are only teachers because they were not naturally talented enough to make a living at their chosen subject...you see this the most in the Arts, like fine arts, writing, music, acting, ect...
Posted November 01, 2009
spunkyduckling says:
This is a tough one and then again maybe not so tough. I merit teachers (those who can teach) because education is such an important part of our lives. But nothing in life is a one way street..it takes two..would there be teachers if there weren't any students. So who makes who?
Education is not what you get or put in its what you bring out. We already have it inside of us and teachers just help us bring that out. God is the only teacher and deserves the highest merit. After all who taught the first teachers? Where does all our knowledge come from?
Posted October 31, 2009
No! Can't agree with this!
yomama says:
Teachers are incapable of getting jobs in the real world. They choose teaching, a career they know does not pay well, because of the job security involved. They are overpaid cowards
Posted February 25, 2011
Momsbusy247 says:
I am a teacher and that saying really angers me! Everyone who is anyone was taught by teachers for at least 12 years.... really, can we be that bad?
Posted November 01, 2010
Aysha says:
Yes and No!
No because....teaching in itself is a skill and talent that not all of us have. It is not easy to pass on the knowledge that you got to others...To engage their attention and follow through to ensure that they got it...that isnt easy!
Yes because not all of us have the opportunity to "do what we know" the point is we teach it as we dont get to do it..but we want to be able to spread the knowledge to others...and that shouldnt be used to devalue teachers and educators as a whole at all!!
Its true that most of us are where we are because of our teachers. The fact that they chose to educate and enlighten us is a praiseworthy one and should never be demeaned or belittled.
Posted May 20, 2010
JuneMary says:
Those who "can't", can't teach either!
You have to be well educated in many disciplines, especially in HOW to teach or you can't do it.
However, that doesn't mean that all "teachers" can teach!
Posted January 02, 2010
Brookelorren says:
It helps to know what you're doing to teach. Many teachers choose their profession before they have set out to find out whether they'd succeed or not outside academia. At the college level, many teachers have succeeded outside the classroom... received nobel prizes, represent people in state congress, written successful books, etc.
Posted November 05, 2009
drifter0658 says:
I will never agree to this. I have learned from many doers over the years, and have seen many teachers who could out so any doers in their field.
One of the best English teachers I ever had was hired by the school system primarily as the High School Baseball coach. As it turned out, Rick Dill was one of the best English teachers to have ever taught in that school system.
More than a handful of my college professors gave up rising stars in their profession to teach others about their field.
Posted November 04, 2009
AddaptAbilities says:
Like many cliches, this is one that oversimplifies the issue and completely overlooks the fact that "teaching" is a verb. By definition, it is something that one does.
I had a completely different experience from MysticMama. It was my primary grade teachers who were awful. When I got to junior high, high school, and college, I was finally taught by teachers who loved their subject and loved imparting knowledge about that subject.
I also disagree with the assertion that artists who teach do so because "they weren't naturally talented enough to make a living at their chosen subject" . "Making it" in the arts has less to do with talent and more do to with luck, the luxury of being able to devote time to your work, and whether someone powerful decides that you or your work is "marketable".
The artists I know who teach for income are all successful in their various disciplines. They are "making it". They decided to teach because, in addition to the financial stability that comes with a regular gig, they genuinely love teaching. They love mentoring talent in others, they love imparting knowledge about their subject, and they love the challenge of communicating their expertise to others.
Now, I'm off to teach an well-planned art lesson to a dearly-loved student :)
Posted November 03, 2009
prosperity66 says:
Well, having worked in schools for many years, I would say that you MUST have educational skills to teach. Most of those I met in my daily job and who were teaching because they couldn't do the job they chose were unable to teach properly. This is what makes the quality of teaching decrease. Teaching is like a priesthood and demands a great deal of sacrifices in addition to the needed skills.
Posted November 03, 2009
skiesgreen says:
Its just something that the non intelligent think is funny and, therefore, cool to quote. It is insulting and degrading to the wonderful supportive teachers who struggle to give people like that the basics they need in order to think, read and write. That doesn't mean that all teachers are geniuses or have the skills to cope with the few who are not able to be educated.
Posted November 02, 2009
Cinetech says:
Not true at all. IMO this is a truer statement: Those who can teach, they are rare. Those who can do, they are many.
Posted November 01, 2009
Ramkitten says:
Like Bethd821, I always interpreted this to mean that people who studied other professions--say, law or engineering or writing--who weren't successful in their field turned to teaching those disciplines instead. Still, I don't agree with that statement. I believe one has to really know what he or she is doing in order to teach the skills to others.
Posted November 01, 2009
bethd821 says:
I never put it in the context of teachers. I thought it pertained to other professions, not teachers.
Posted October 31, 2009
capriliz says:
That sentence can be true at times. Overall, I think it is very inaccurate. I know of professionals who left high paying jobs to teach our kids. I also know of teachers that my kids have had who could have run circles around some of the "professionals" in the business world. But, they choose to remain in the public school system to help our kids. I think that is very noble.
Posted October 31, 2009
Evelyn_Saenz says:
Teaching should be the highest paid position in the world. Teachers are the ones who prepare students to become presidents, CEO's and peace activists.
Posted October 31, 2009
Another Cliche - Teachers Work 5 hours a Day at Most!
People see only the work in the classroom as the only work teachers do!

I have heard different people with different backgrounds saying to my husband who happens to be a teacher: "You are overpaid - you work like 5 hours a day!" And this is so untrue! Those people don't know and don't care about the numerous nights he stayed awake preparing everything for a school project before an upcoming holiday or some other integrated project.
There is so much teachers do behind the closed doors of their homes! They have to prepare to be able to stand in front of the kids and teach! Teaching is not just talking! School lessons have to have a flow, a structure and rarely would any teacher come to class unprepared! But this many parents don't see or count as working hours!
Image credit: A Plus Kid by stick_figures
Calling all Teachers!
Help me break these cliches!
Teacher's Poll: How Many Hours A Day....
... you spend preparing for your class?
We are talking here about an average hours you spend each day for preparation for class, including paperwork, rating papers, checking homework, etc. And we're talking about teachers with full-time job!
What Do Teachers Do Exactly?
Add a responsability or duty you are obligated to fulfill as a teacher...
... and vote for those you consider the most important! Help others (parents and students) understand how teachers see their profession!
Encourage Students
Many teachers encourage and inspire by their attit more...5 points
Produce well-rounded people who are capable of stepping out into the world with knowledge and confidence
I never "taught a subject". I educated kids. more...3 points
Make the World a Better Place
Only through education can we improve our world.2 points
Put up with unreasonable and/or irate parents
Many parents do nothing towards the education of t more...2 points
Teachers - Underpaid or Overpaid?
What do you think of this?
Do you think teachers should be paid more, or they are already overpaid for the work they do?
Fetching blurbs now... please stand byTeachers are underpaid!
Momsbusy247 says:
Take your own kids multiply them by 30 and you spend 7 hrs with them locked in a room, 5 days a week and you tell me if teachers get enough money. Most parents send their kids to school to get away from them.
Posted November 01, 2010
Dave Clarke says:
Most school system teachers are highly dedicated people. They go far beyond and above what most people do in their jobs. The problem with the school system is the excess administration and lack of discipline in the classroom, which is simply insane. Teachers are forced to become glorified "baby sitters" because of this. If a student isn't there to learn send them home and let their parents deal with them but give parents back the right to even do that. Too many "do gooders" have hog tied parents ability to control their kids.
Posted December 20, 2009
AddaptAbilities says:
It seems like teachers are underpaid where it matters most. From what I understand, many new teachers in the US don't make a living wage, and are vulnerable to budget cuts and hiring freezes; while senior teachers in certain districts can make a decent living.
As for those communities living with the stress of poverty and crime, nobody gets paid well, and it's hard for their schools to hold on to talented teachers.
Posted November 03, 2009
prosperity66 says:
This all depends on their country. I know for a fact that French teachers have a bigger salary than Belgians, Americans are more paid than Europeans, and so on. So, the debate is biased...
However, I would say that for working 20 effective hours in schools (in the secundary classes) + 18 hours after school, preparing (hum... they don't prepare like before, at least in my country, everything comes from books, copied and they write nothing any more!), they're paid enough as in my country, they get a salary almost equal to the monthly social allocation a jobless gets - +/- 1200 euros/month.
Posted November 03, 2009
nickupton says:
Underpaid for sure. This is why many of the most able teachers leave because they can earn more money excelling in their chosen field.
It is a shame that society values soccer players and racing drivers over teachers.
Posted November 02, 2009
Teachers are overpaid!
Why We Teach by Sonia Nieto
Why teach? Listen to the voices of both veteran and new teachers as they share their most heartfelt and thoughtful replies to this simple but important question. Sonia Nieto, a distinguished teacher in her own right, has gathered the insights and inspirations of K-12 classroom teachers as they examine how and why they find purpose and value in the work they do. The teachers in this book, like so many across the country, do the kind of work that may not grab headlines but is far more important than even the highest test score: These teachers listen closely to their students. They share in their students' struggles and successes. They create a classroom climate that encourages growth, direction, and purpose. They help students develop into thoughtful, engaged citizens. The teachers in this book show us the kinds of learning that really matter, and the kinds of lessons that students can take with them for their entire lives. This inspirational book focuses on the quintessential values of teaching, challenges current notions that focus on only accountability, testing, and standardization, and provide a compelling message of hope for public education.
Why We Teach
Amazon Price: $12.00 (as of 02/16/2012)![]()
List Price: $21.95
Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Stand for the Best: What I Learned after Leaving My Job as CEO of H&R Block to Become a Teacher and Founder of an Inner-City Charter School by Thomas M.Bloch
Thirteen years ago, Tom Bloch was CEO of H&R Block, the groundbreaking tax organization. The son of the company's founder, he was a happily married 41-year-old executive, but something was missing from his life. After a nineteen-year career at the company, Bloch resigned his position to become a math teacher in an impoverished inner-city section of Kansas City. Stand for the Best reveals Bloch's struggles to make a difference for his marginalized students and how he eventually co-founded a successful charter school, University Academy.
Stand for the Best: What I Learned after Leaving My Job as CEO of H&R Block to Become a Teacher and Founder of an Inner-City Charter School
Amazon Price: $2.80 (as of 02/16/2012)![]()
List Price: $24.95
Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Some of the famous teachers!
Memorable Quotations: Famous Teachers and Educators (A - H)
Great quotes from Allan Bloom and company.0 points
Famous Teachers - AOL Living
What do Gene Simmons, Mr. T and Andy Griffith all more...0 points
Famous Teachers - Famous Teacher - Teachers Famous around the World
Teachers are inevitable part of our lives. They pl more...0 points
See Me After Class: Advice for Teachers by Teachers
This is the book that will save rookies' souls when they lose the strength to save their classrooms. With tales from more than one hundred veterans from across the country, teachers everywhere will find themselves laughing, maybe crying, and definitely taking notes. Readers at the toughest schools will be relieved to find a resource that deals specifically with their struggles instead of insisting that all teaching situations are the same. This is the book that will keep the great teachers of the future from quitting before they become great.
Many new teachers have been waiting for someone to break the "stay positive!" code and talk about the parts of the job that make teachers question their career choices. While other books cover the eyes of readers to keep from scaring them, this one asks teachers to be brutally honest about how tough teaching truly is and whether the rewards are still worth it. The answer is yes.
See Me After Class: Advice for Teachers by Teachers
Amazon Price: $44.61 (as of 02/16/2012)![]()
List Price: $19.95
Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Related News About Teachers Online
- Contest would focus on teacher quality
- WASHINGTON (AP) ? Education Secretary Arne Duncan on Wednesday spelled out details of a proposed new $5 billion Race to the Top-style competition focused on improving teacher quality. Among the changes the administration is seeking: higher teaching ...
- Basalt High teacher faces felony charge for alleged relationship with student
- by Chad Abraham, Aspen Daily News Staff Writer An arrest warrant was issued Wednesday for a Basalt High School teacher and coach who allegedly had a sexual relationship with a student that started in the fall. Lauren Redfern, 26, of El Jebel, ...
- Another LA teacher accused of student sex crimes
- By Michael Winter, USA TODAY The Los Angeles district attorney today charged a high school teaching assistant who coached girls' sports with four sex felonies for allegedly having an "inappropriate relationship" with a 15-year-old student, ...
- Lawmakers seek to change teacher seniority rules
- Republicans look to end the ?last in, first out? teacher layoff scenario in which teachers with the most seniority are automatically retained. The Senate Education Committee on Monday, Feb. 13 took testimony on Wolf's bill, which, if passed and signed ...
Teach Like Your Hair's on Fire
In a Los Angeles neighborhood plagued by guns, gangs, and drugs, there is an exceptional classroom known as Room 56. The fifth graders inside are first-generation immigrants who live in poverty and speak English as a second language. They also play Vivaldi, perform Shakespeare, score in the top 1 percent on standardized tests, and go on to attend Ivy League universities. Rafe Esquith is the teacher responsible for these accomplishments.
From the man whom The New York Times calls "a genius and a saint" comes a revelatory program for educating today's youth. In Teach Like Your Hair's on Fire!, Rafe Esquith reveals the techniques that have made him one of the most acclaimed educators of our time. The two mottoes in Esquith's classroom are "Be Nice, Work Hard," and "There Are No Shortcuts." His students voluntarily come to school at 6:30 in the morning and work until 5:00 in the afternoon. They learn to handle money responsibly, tackle algebra, and travel the country to study history. They pair Hamlet with rock and roll, and read the American classics. Teach Like Your Hair's on Fire! is a brilliant and inspiring road map for parents, teachers, and anyone who cares about the future success of our nation's children.
Teach Like Your Hair's on Fire: The Methods and Madness Inside Room 56
Amazon Price: $8.87 (as of 02/16/2012)![]()
List Price: $24.95
Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Another question with need for an answer!
Can beauty compensate for a brain?
What's the Most Important Thing you Learned from Your Teacher?
Share it with the rest of the world...
... and help me prove my point here! After that, go grab your school album and remind yourself of the great teachers and all the friends you made during school years!
-
Reply
-
tandemonimom
Mar 17, 2011 @ 3:58 pm | delete
- Great debate! ** BLESSED ** and featured on Blessed by Tandemonimom! Also lensrolled to Why I Chose Homeschool.
-
-
Reply
-
Momsbusy247 Nov 1, 2010 @ 6:34 pm | delete
- To believe in the children who never believed in themselves. I became a teacher because of other great teachers who I wanted to emulate.
-
-
Reply
-
aishu19
May 20, 2010 @ 10:57 am | delete
- Well done Michelle! Most of my friends are teachers and I can certainly appreciate their efforts more and glad that you can put that message out to the world...
-
-
Reply
-
JuneMary
Jan 2, 2010 @ 2:29 pm | delete
- I was lucky in that most of my teachers were really good teachers and I learnt to be curious.
I collect information like other people collect ornaments or teddy bears.
-
-
Reply
-
JoyfulPamela
Nov 6, 2009 @ 8:49 pm | delete
- Thank you for this well done article. I can't imagine being anything but a teacher. I love teaching! It's exhausting and hard work, but when their little faces light up with something you are encouraging them with, it is certainly worth it all.
-
-
Reply
-
Evelyn_Saenz Nov 4, 2009 @ 9:12 am | delete
- My teachers taught me that no child is a failure. My teachers taught me to love learning. My teachers taught me that no matter how hard the subject is there is a way to understand and the key is to find the way to make that subject interesting.
-
-
Reply
-
ulla_hennig
Nov 4, 2009 @ 8:42 am | delete
- Whenever a teacher was passionate I loved the subject he taught. Passionate regarding the subjects and passionate regarding the kids. Without passion no good teaching is possible.
-
-
Reply
-
drifter0658
Nov 4, 2009 @ 8:31 am | delete
- The most important thing I learned from any of my teachers was passion. Be passionate about life and much knowledge will flow your way.
Awesome lens!
Smell the smoke?
-
-
Reply
-
AddaptAbilities
Nov 3, 2009 @ 3:59 pm | delete
- My mother in law thinks teachers are "overpaid" because their day is done at 3 pm, they get all that vacation, etc, whereas my father in law (now retired) worked until 6, etc.
I've taught in various settings -- music lessons, art lessons, adjunct/guest faculty, after-school enrichment programs, Girl Scouts ... . I told my MIL that on days when I taught, even though I only spent two hours in the classroom, I worked twice as hard in those two hours alone than my husband works in a typical eight hour day. Kid-wrangling is HARD WORK.
-
-
Reply
-
prosperity66
Nov 3, 2009 @ 6:55 am | delete
- Well, a well put together lens. However, a biased debate since all countries don't face the same problems and their teaching system don't work in the same way. But worth to read.
Dom.
-
- Load More
I'm not a Teacher.
I'm married to a teacher.
by a_willow
Welcome! My name is Michelle Willow. I'm a mother of beautiful little girl who brings me joy every day. Wife of a very patient man. Daughter of loving... more »
- 152 featured lenses
- Winner of 20 trophies!
- Top lens » How to Reuse Paper Rolls

