Home » Food & Cooking » Recipes » Side Dish Recipes

Tomato Pie Recipe

Ranked #781 in Food & Cooking, #14,458 overall | Donates to Friends of the Park

A Combination of Tomato Pie Recipes

Yummy! I took the Tomato Pie Recipes from three friends and combined "this" from one and "that" from another. The Tomato Pie sure was good and easy to make!

Thank you to my friends for sharing their recipes and helpful hints. I needed all the help I could get!

I was first introduced to Tomato Pie about 10 years ago so I am really not sure how long the recipe has been around. This is actually my first time to make it but I had eaten it many times before.

Here is the Tomato Pie Recipe as I made it and I hope you enjoy it as much as we do!

Tomato Pie Recipe Card

Easy Tomato Pie Recipe

Printable Version

Tomato Pie Recipe right on your Apron

I saw this done by Susan52 and thought it was a neat idea

Tomato Pie Recipe Apron apron
Tomato Pie Recipe Apron by ohmeakanancy
Design an apron at zazzle

Wear your favorite recipe on your apron!

Have you ever eaten or made Tomato Pie?

Tell me what you think about Tomato Pie!

Loading poll. Please Wait...

Now you have your recipe, let's get the ingredients together

This Tomato Pie Recipe can be varied so don't be afraid to get creative!

Ingredients for Tomato Pie
3 or 4 ripe tomatoes diced
1 - 9 in pie shell (of course, you can make
your own if you want to)
1 c finely diced onion or 2 green onions chopped
1 pkg of Good Seasons Italian Dressing Mix or a
mixture of your favorite fresh herbs
Note: Most of the time I just use 1/2 pkg
Salt and Pepper
1 c Mayonaise
1 c grated cheddar cheese

Next you will need to prepare your tomatoes and onions

3 tomatoes if they are large, 4 if they are smaller


While your pie crust is pre-baking,
do the following:

I always peel my tomatoes before dicing
but this is a personal preference. I have never tried this Tomato Pie Recipe with canned tomatoes but may have to do that this winter.

Spread your diced tomatoes on a baking sheet,
salt and let sit for several minutes.
Then rinse and pat dry with a paper towel.
Note: This helpful hint was on my friend's recipe
that she got from
Grits and Groceries Restaurant Website

Layer 1/2 of the tomatoes topped with
1/2 of the onions and sprinkle with
1/3 of the Italian Dressing Mix.
Add another layer with the remaining
tomatoes and onions and
sprinkle that with 1/3 of the dressing mix.

One of my friends likes to add extra Oregano,
Basil, and other spices.

Do you have a good Tomato Knife and Food Chopper?

Click the Amazon Link to purchase or to search further


Wusthof 4105 Gourmet Fork Tip Tomato Knife 5-in.



Zyliss Easy Chop Food Chopper with Smart Base



These are two items that would sure come in handy when preparing your Tomato Pie!

Now for the Icing of your Tomato Pie

Spread this topping all over the top of the pie, add salt and pepper


Ice with the mixture of grated cheese,
mayonaise and remaining dressing mix.

I have found that Sharp Cheddar is better
for cooking than Extra Sharp.
The Extra seems to get grainy.

Paula Deen's Pie Dish Should Do The Trick

I imagine that Paula Deen makes a great Tomato Pie, wouldn't you?

I usually take a prepared pie crust and transfer it into a nice looking pie pan but that isn't really necessary


Paula Deen 9 Inch Stoneware Pie Baker, Green

Bake your Tomato Pie at 350 degrees until Golden Brown

Cheese should be bubbly and onions cooked

Mine was still a little runny but still tasted great. My hubby said, "That's right tasty!"

You can see a section of the done pie looks a little different. That is because I cut it before it was completely done. I just had to go ahead and eat the cut portion! Sorry about that! I guess the saying "Patience is a Virtue, is true!"

This Tomato Pie Recipe lens was featured on Cabaret Squidoo Best Recipes

Thank you, Robin

Loading Fetching RSS feed... please stand by

A different Tomato Pie Recipe found on Cooking Up A Story

Cooking Up A Story is a show about people, food and sustainable living

Thank you to Rebecca Gerendasy for giving me permission to add this video to my lens. Please visit Cooking Up A Story

Cooking Up a Story, strives to build communities around the many important and interconnected issues that involve food and sustainability. We produce three shows about people, food, and sustainable living: Stories consists of documentary shorts about farmers, artisan producers, and others; FOOD NEWS features interviews with experts on the science, politics, and culture of food; and Cooking Fresh showcases food enthusiasts as they demonstrate how to cook fresh seasonal foods.
Tomato Pie
by cookingupastory | video info

95 ratings | 92,217 views
curated content from YouTube

Tomato Pie found on Google News

Check out what others are saying about Tomato Pie

Recipe: Shepherd's Pie with Buttered Baby Vegetables
Add tomatoes, tomato puree, stock, bay leaf, rosemary and thyme. Simmer, covered, 30 minutes. Season with Worcestershire, salt and pepper to taste. 4. Meanwhile, make the topping. Boil potatoes and parsnips in water until soft.
Reader Mail: More on tomato-y beef stew, fresh mozzarella, Whole Foods and ...
A reader left a message on my voicemail asking where to find beef stew made with tomatoes rather than a brown gravy base. We had several suggestions from our faithful followers. Thanks, gang. One reader said that beef stew made with tomatoes is a ...
Tomato and Cheese Lunch Pie turns out beautifully
By Elizabeth Pudwill Cindy Lane asked about a recipe for Tomato Pie. This one came in from a reader and comes out so beautifully. Serve this pie as a side dish or have a big piece for lunch. Amy Ibarra wrote in saying her grandmother used to make ...
Al Calozzi Introduces Trenton Tomato Pies
9 2012 at 11:00 AM ?Four months after the planned first firing of his new pizza oven, Al Calozzi's finally secured the permit to sell tomato pies at his eponymous Pioneer Square cheese steak joint. "We had thought that we'd be starting sooner, ...
Powered by Google

Charlino has her own version of Tomato Pie

This Italian Tomato Pie sure sounds great, too!

Charlino's recipe for Italian Tomato Pie sounds great but I would have to leave off the Basil. I don't know why I don't like Basil but I don't.
Italian Tomato Pie
Check out this Italian Tomato Pie recipe and Charlino has a printable Recipe Card on this page just for you.

Friends Found this page and shared their Tomato Pie story and photo!

Thank you, Donna and Earl Preeper

Tomato Pie by Donna Preeper"Hi Nancy Thanks for the link to the tomato pie recipe. We have lots of tomatoes and that was a perfect recipe to use some, plus I had never tried a tomato pie. I did not have a pkg of the Italian dressing mix, so I used fresh basil,thyme and rosemary from my herb garden. I also watched the video from your link(cooking up a story) and used the caramelized onion idea to top the pie. That made it very tasty. I then just top the onions off with mozzarella. Thanks again for the link. Donna

PS we ate the entire pie except for 2 slices! Em em good"

Note: Earl is the owner of Alpha-Dog Dog Obedience Training and he has been working with us and our Bulldog, Bruno! We sure have learned a lot.

This Tomato Pie Recipe is featured on Squidoo Chefmasters - Recipes & More

Thank you thrivingmom

Loading Fetching RSS feed... please stand by

I hope you and your family enjoy this Tomato Pie as much as we do!

Tomato Pie

More Ohme's Recipes

This page is a directory of all my Recipes on Squidoo

Ohme's Recipes
Recipes for Fruit Salad, Hen Mulligan, Peach Ice Cream and much more.

Tell me about your favorite recipe using fresh tomatoes

Did you like this Tomato Pie Recipe?

I would love to hear how you make Tomato Pie as well as other Tomato Recipes.
I have never made this in the winter with canned tomatoes but may have to try it this winter and will let you know how it taste.

submit
Show All

Stepping Up To The Plate for Veterans Park in Pendleton SC

All Donations are appreciated!

Since the 3 friends who shared their recipes with me are all members of Friends of the Park, I decided to donate 100% of the royalties on this page to our charitable organization, Friends of the Park. We are working hard on a Step Up To The Plate Fundraising Campaign to raise $200,000 to renovate the ball fields and erect a Veterans Memorial at our Veterans Park. We hope you will Step Up To The Plate, too!

If you prefer not to use this donation box, your tax deductible donation may be mailed to:
Friends of the Park
PO Box 408
Pendleton SC 29670

Thank you!

We are a group of concerned citizens interested in making Pendleton SC's Veterans Park the best it can be. We currently have a playground, walking trail, three picnic shelters, a concessions pavilion with restrooms, and three old ballfields.

by

OhMe

Tomato Pie is delicious. If you have never had it, I hope you will try it especially if you love tomatoes.
Look below and what do you see? It's a Purple... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!

Explore related pages

More Pages by Ohme 

Just click the link to find more great recipes

Loading

Yummy, these recipes sound delicious and right up my alley! 

Click the product to purchase or to browse around Amazon

Fannie Flagg's Original Whistle Stop Cafe Cookbook: Featuring : Fried Green Tomatoes, Southern Barbecue, Banana Split Cake, and Many Other Great Recipes

Fannie Flagg's Original Whistle Stop Cafe Cookbook: Featuring : Fried Green Tomatoes, Southern Barbecue, Banana Split Cake, and Many Other Great Recipes

by: Fannie Flagg

Amazon Price: $6.58 (as of 02/15/2012)Buy Now

I would love some Fried Green Tomatoes along with my Tomato Pie. You just can't have too many tomatoes, in my opinion!

Southern Living's Favorite Southern Dives 

Click product to purchase or to browse around Amazon.com

Southern Living Off the Eaten Path: Favorite Southern Dives and 150 Recipes that Made Them Famous

Southern Living Off the Eaten Path: Favorite Southern Dives and 150 Recipes that Made Them Famous

by: Morgan Murphy, Editors of Southern Living Magazine

Amazon Price: $12.30 (as of 02/15/2012)Buy Now

A friend of mine purchased this book and said there are some wonderful recipes in it. She said that the restaurant Grits and Groceries has their Tomato Pie Recipe in this book. Sounds great to me!

Related Tags