Is Twilight Appropriate For Kids?

1 - I can do better 2 - Jury's out 3 - Pretty darn good 4 - Splendiferous 5 - Awesometastic by 19 people | Log in to rate

Ranked #14 in Books, #1,138 overall

What Parents Want To Know

With the release of the highly anticipated vampire romance movies based on the Twilight Saga books by Stephenie Meyer, many parents are wondering if the Twilight book series and movies are appropriate for kids.

Read what others are saying and add your opinion in the polls and debates below!

The final book in the series, Breaking Dawn, brings a lot of mature themes to the story line that you may not be expecting. Before you let your daughter read the 4th book in the Twilight vampire saga you may want to read what others are saying.

My 13 year old daughter is absolutely addicted to the Twilight saga by Stephenie Meyer. She introduced the books to me and we both LOVE them.

Please Note: This is not meant to discourage you or anyone else from reading the books or watching the movie. It's just a heads-up in case your aren't sure about the content for younger children.

Read what others are saying and add your opinion in the polls and debates below!

 

 

WARNING: 

Possible Twilight Saga movies & books spoilers below!!

Photobucket

 

Photobucket

 

Photobucket

Twilight is a romantic-fantasy film directed by Catherine Hardwicke and based on the novel of the same name by Stephenie Meyer. It focuses on the development of a personal relationship between human teenager Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) and vampire Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson), and the subsequent efforts of Cullen and his family to keep Swan safe from a separate group of hostile vampires.

The project was in development for approximately three years at Paramount Pictures, during which time a screen adaptation which differed significantly from the novel was written. Summit Entertainment acquired the rights to the novel after three years of the project's stagnant development. Melissa Rosenberg wrote a new adaptation of the novel shortly before the 2007?2008 Writers Guild of America strike and sought to be faithful to the novel's storyline. The film was primarily shot in Washington and Oregon in early 2008.

Twilight was released in theaters on November 21, 2008, and grossed US$35.7 million on its opening day. As of September 19, 2009, the film has grossed US$383,520,177 in worldwide box office and, as of July 12, 2009, $157,078,128 in North American DVD sales. The soundtrack was released on November 4, 2008. New Moon and Eclipse, the next two books in the series, were produced as films the following year.

New Moon Movie 

New Moon is rated PG-13 for some violence and action.



Don't get sold out! Buy advance tickets to the Twilight Saga's New Moon!

powered by Youtube

 

The Twilight Saga: New Moon [Theatrical Release]

Amazon Price: (as of 11/25/2009)Buy Now

Is The Twilight Movie Appropriate For Kids? 

The Twilight movie is rated PG-13 for some violence and a scene of sensuality

Loading poll. Please Wait...

 

Twilight On DVD 

Twilight (Two-Disc Special Edition)

Amazon Price: $19.49 (as of 11/25/2009)Buy Now

 

Photobucket

 

Photobucket

Twilight is a series of four vampire-based fantasy romance novels by American author Stephenie Meyer. It charts a period in the life of Isabella "Bella" Swan, a teenage girl who moves to Forks, Washington and falls in love with a 104-year-old vampire named Edward Cullen. The series is told primarily from Bella's point of view, with the epilogue of Eclipse and Part II of Breaking Dawn being told from the viewpoint of character Jacob Black, a werewolf. The unpublished Midnight Sun is a retelling of the first book, Twilight, from Edward Cullen's point of view.

Ever since the release of the first novel, Twilight, in 2005, the books have gained immense popularity and commercial success around the world. The series is most popular among young adults; the four books have won multiple awards, most notably the 2008 British Book Award for "Children's Book of the Year" for Breaking Dawn, while the series as a whole won the 2009 Kids' Choice Award for Favorite Book.

As of November 2009, the series has sold over 85 million copies worldwide with translations into at least 38 different languages around the globe. The four Twilight books have consecutively set records as the biggest selling novels of 2008 on the USA Today Best-Selling Books list and have spent over 235 weeks on the New York Times Best Seller list for Children's Series Books.

Thus far, the first three books are being made into a series of motion pictures by Summit Entertainment; the film adaptation of Twilight was released in 2008 and the second, New Moon, was released on November 20, 2009.

Is The Twilight Book Series Appropriate For Kids? 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

 

Photobucket

Add Your 2 Cents Here: 

*Please discuss the Breaking Dawn book HERE!

What age group is the Twilight Saga appropriate for and why?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

13 & Up Only

Taylor says:

They're both unattractive, misogynistic, one-dimensional, fictional characters.

Twi-Hard! says:

I adore the Twilight books, and I can't wait to share them with my daughters but I absolutely wouldn't dream of letting them read them until they are at least 14. My eldest daughter is 9, and is a very advanced reader - she is currently reading Charles Dickens - so I don't think vocabulary or comprehension would be an issue for her. However, for me the Twilight Saga is about intense love and intense lust, neither of which have any relevence to the life of a child.
It is definitely a book for teenagers - I think the ideal age to get the most from the books would be 16/17, ie Bella's age at the start.
Let children be children.

Elise says:

This book is first and foremost a romance novel. What child under 13 could possibly understand romance? I'd barely gone through puberty at that point in my life. Of course, with romance comes sexual themes. I don't understand how parents don't understand this as it seems clear to me.

Amanda Cullen says:

I read the whole series, I'm 15. I would never want my 10 yr old sister to read the books until she is 14, but thats how she is. I think it depends on the kid, and the parents. I could have read this when I was 12 I think, but thats who I am, and my maturity level. . ..

dazee192 says:

i think i missed the part of the series that describes bella's "abusive boyfriend" - can anyone help me out with that? i am trying to decide if these books are appropriate for my nearly 13-year old stepdaughter. i'm almost positive that she's ready for twilight & probably new moon, too - but i think i may draw the line at eclipse & breaking dawn for now though. i know that she and her friends talk about sex, and honestly i don't think they have the healthiest viewpoint on it, even for tweens - they're very explicit in their language about it. they say things i have a hard time saying! anyway, i think what bella has with edward is special and i would want my stepdaughter to see this novel for what it really is - an incredibly romantic fantasy (and not in the "fabio novel" way). if only i could guarantee that she would see it that way!

Faith says:

Thank you Tania! I think your inappropriately aged fowl language has proven the point of "worried" and everyone else with similar concerns. In the future as you gain maturity, which is evident you do not have, you may learn bullying your point across with unintelligent language and personal attacks makes you look like the fool every time.

pragmatist says:

subtract the supernatural premise and you have a teenage protagonist who sneaks her boyfriend into her room nightly to watch her sleep. her boy friend disables her car to prevent her from visiting her friend. He enlists the aid of his family to isolate and prevent her from seeing the only friend who complains about his controlling behavior. When he breaks up with her she collapses into a semi-catatonic state lasting for several months. She then engages in dangerous stunts such as approaching strange men loitering in front of bars and jumping off a cliff to get her ex-boyfriends attention. He attempts suicide when he believes his girlfriend is dead. Young readers lack the emotional maturity to differentiate between controlling relationships and healthy romantic interests. As for the vampirism, I see very little difference between Edward and My Little Ponies. They are both vegetarians who sparkle in sunlight.

amandascloset0 says:

I honostly think the age on these movies & books should be a bit closer to 17 before it is appropriate for them. Based on the dark demonic imagery and themes as well as the violence and sensuality. Just my opinion.

the lamb says:

I think it's the parents decision. you know perental guidance and all that. some bits might be a bit grown up. But it's not like it goes into detail or anything, it only hints at that stuff.

Ash says:

The twilight series was made for teens , it is from the point of view of a teenage girl and things that we go through like falling in love and their is a lot of sexual thoughts about boys around that age.it drives me crazy seeing these little children having twilight parties because they shouldn't know about alot of these things because it wasn't made for them. Twilight is strictly for teens

Anonymous says:

It's not really that violent, people just misinterpret it as violent because there is very physical sexual content. I personally love the series, but I think parents should read the novel ahead of time or maybe a maturity content warning.

After all, the first movie was rated PG-13 so that should be a head's up already.

kris says:

i thinkthey should be for people 13 and up because they are not going to understand all the stuff in breaking dawn i mean only if they are really mature but they might missunderstand it . i dont remember it to be violent but yes there is a lot of sensuality and sex so its up to you but i dont think its for litle kids

Rosa says:

Even though i say 13+ people should understand that it doesn't actually describe the sex scenes with detail or info for that fact so its perfectly OK. Read its awsome

samy says:

i think it's ok for them to watch.It all depends on how mature the person is. A lot of people say i am pretty mature for my age and i am 15 and they also say that i am a tiny,crazy punk too but who cares.and besides how can we keep them from watching something AMAZING.

samy says:

i say for 13 and up becouse they already know what's going on i mean common some even already have girlfriends or boyfriends. I think it's ok for them to watch this.how can we keep them from something AMAZING.

Marie Dove says:

I beleive it all depends on how mature your child is. It might not be right for them and they may get obbsesed, get depressed, or try to be like the characters. Explain to them that it's just a book and it's not really?

TwilightGirl says:

I think it's appropriate for 14 and up.
Stephenie Meyer is a mormon and so the books don't have much sex or violence.
I'm 15 and the amount of sexual content is basically just about less than what 15 year olds hear every day.
I think it's okay for them to begin reading the series while they are at the end of 13. I know 13 year olds, and I would laugh if they were reading Eclipse or Breaking Dawn merely because I'd find it vaguely amusing to see their embarassed looks if their parents had a look at what they were reading.
If your daughters have read the first two I wouldn't ban them from reading the 3rd and 4th, but if you feel they are inappropriate then allow them to read the first couple of chapters of Midnight Sun on Stephenie Meyers website. It's Edward's account of the events of Twilight and so far it is absolutely amazing!!!
Meanwhile, you might want to have a read yourself....or try Stephenie Meyer's The Host.

well, that's all, from your Twilight Fanpire friend.

worried says:

I am tired of reading opinions of little girls on here! The whole point of this survey is to decide if little girls should be watching\reading this series. Of course little girls think it is alright, they always know what is best for themselves, right? It's crap like this that parents let their young ones watch\read that is helping to contribute to youth pregnancy and such. Shame on our society for constantly selling sex to our youth.

rachel w says:

i think it depends on how mature the person is i have watched the film and read all the books and i am 11 but a lot of people say i am very very mature for my age
P.S. i am addicted to twilight but for the majority of kids i would say 13+

frisco says:

no way too much sex in these books
not for anyone under the age of 16

It's Okay For Kids Younger Than 13

Indiana says:

I'm eleven and my mum wanted till I was eleven to read it. I've read Twilight and New Moon and my Mum brought me Eclipse. I think I'm aloud to read Breaking Dawn but that's because Mum don't know what happens. I personally wouldn't want my sister (if she likes Twilight series) to read Breaking Dawn till she's 13.
But that's just my view.

Lani says:

I think it's okay for ten year olds to read if they understand the contents. Like if they can't read the words they shouldn't read it. I'm 11 and I read the book because I can understand it.

Kook says:

i think 9 year olds can read it!
my daughter is and she loves them and she is still the sweet girl she used to be so i think it is 9-and up appropriate.

onedragon933 says:

if the kid is really interested on it let them and if they understand on what it's about then their the right age.

anna says:

I am 12 years old and I think Twiligh is appropriate for all ages from 8 and up

Katie says:

It really depends on how mature your kid is. My mom let's me read books and see movies that 14 year olds arent aloud to see and im 11.

bobbison says:

I'd say if you aready know what sex is and you've gone through the "talk" then it's ok. In school my class got the talk when I was 11. I think that's the age for most kids. Maybe 10. As long as you understand it is wrong and it's just a book, then why not.

Chloe says:

I am 12 and I am only on the beginning of breaking dawn so i'm not sure how bad that one is but, twilight and new moon are fine. Slight cussing but the words aren't REALLY bad. Eclipse I would say, suggests things that might be bad for a kid under like 10. But, there is the fact that younger kids might not be able to comprehend the books, I can do it just fine, but, that is me. I personally say, that as long as the kid is mature enough to handle it, go ahead.

me says:

yes yess

Tania says:

IM WITH YOU BELLA CULLEN!! WORRIED NEEDS TO SHUT THE FCK UP!! WERE NOT GONNA BE A PREGNANT TEEN MAYBE THATS JUST WORRIED'S FAMILY MEMBER CUZ HIS FAMILY MEMBER IS PROBOBALLY A BIMBO HO BOY CHASER

Tania says:

WELL WTF IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE???? IM TEN AND I READ IT! IS THAT A PROBLEM?

Isabella Marie Swan Cullen says:

HELL, IT'S OKAY FOR MY ONE-YEAR-OLD COUSIN TO READ THE BOOKS!!!!!!!

Isabella Marie Swan Cullen says:

I am ten and I have read Twilight and New Moon. My dad, at first, didn't care if I read the whole series (he doesn't know anything about the saga). But then my mom went asking around and even though my LIBRARIAN knows me like I'm her own daughter and has read all the books and says it's fine for me to read them all, my kept asking and won't let me read Eclipse or Breaking Dawn. Then she told my dad and he won't let me read them, either. My life sucks -_-

Danielle says:

It is fine for kids over the age of 4

charz says:

Well I'm ten turning 11 in 3 days and I'm not aloud to read breaking dawn. I've read the reviews and it doesnt sound that bad. If my parents knew that I know about what they mean by "adult themes" then they would let me read. In parent teacher inteviews my teacher said i wasnt aloud to read it, but i wanna read it

Leah says:

The entire twilight series are great books. Yes, there is some violence, but it is not too much for young children. There is some sexual content but it is all done in a very tastefull way. The book does not explain in great detail any sexuality. This book is a great book and if you do have some reservations about it, maybe you could read it with your daughter and talk with her every couple of chapters or so about the book and her thoughts or if she have any questions.

Kristy. says:

I am 12 years old and i loveee the twilight saga. i dont think it is appropriate for children 10 and under though. i understand everythign that was in breaking dawn and i dont think it is apropriate for children younger then 10 because of the sexuality and the maturity level. twilight isnt either because of the high vocabulary and comprehension. it is a little too much.

Mirandacullen says:

oh yeah and i just wanna say that its very insulting, that people are saying that parents who let there kids read this are bad parents. I think that people who are saying that should mind there own business, and i think its VERY rude to say someone is a bad parent. If your going to say that parents who let there kids read this are bad parents, That just shows how much CLASS you have, and thats not very much of it! Grow up and get a life!

madeline says:

My mom is reading the first twilight and says the vocabulary is HUGE :-)

ashley says:

10 and up

 
view all 143 comments

 

Photobucket

Are There Hidden Messages In Twilight? 

Is Twilight corrupting our youth with bad moral values?

 

Photobucket

Classic Literature In The Twilight Saga 

Shakespeare, Jane Austen, Emily Bronte & more!

 

Photobucket

About The Final Book In The Twilight Series 

Breaking Dawn

Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, Book 4)

Amazon Price: $9.50 (as of 11/25/2009)Buy Now

My Daughter's Reaction To Breaking Dawn... 

My 13 year old daughter and I attended the midnight release party for Breaking Dawn together with much anticipation for the 4th book in the vampire series. We got home from the party around 1am and agreed to take turns with our single copy. My mistake was to let her have the first go at it because she read all night and was still awake when I got up at 6am. She was so pale that I thought maybe she had become been bitten by a vampire herself. She was nauseous and extremely disturbed by the events that were unfolding in the first few chapters. She refused to sleep because she could not get the story line out of her mind. The thoughts turned to nightmares whenever she fell asleep. She was obviously not prepared for what she was reading and I was to blame for not thinking to read it first.

The first 3 books in the series had a fair amount of intimacy, but I felt that it was written very tactfully and was comfortable with the content. I should not have assumed that Breaking Dawn would continue on the same path. The sex is actually handled with as much tact as possible for a honeymoon between a vampire and a human girl and is probably not as disturbing to a young reader as the events that follow it. Breaking Dawn deals with a lot of mature situations including, pregnancy, abortion, and a very violent and bloody birth.

Admittedly, my daughter's ,lack of sleep probably had a lot to do with the effect the book had on her but she was obviously not prepared to deal with Bella's unexpected pregnancy and Edward's plan to abort the "monster" from her unwilling body.

Yes, I would have let her read it anyway, but if had known I would have read it first and made the decision to talk with her about some of the situations. My advice to parents is to please read Breaking Dawn first and then decide for yourself. This will give you the opportunity to discuss any content that may be questionable for your child to understand.

Update: After reading the book myself I decided to encourage her to continue reading because I knew she wouldn't have closure until she got to the happily ever after. She did finish the book despite the disturbing beginning and has grown to love it as much as the rest of the series!

 

Photobucket

Is Breaking Dawn Appropriate For Younger Readers? (Ages 12 & Under) 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

 

Is Breaking Dawn a good book for young girls to be reading? (ages 12 & under)

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

What's the Big Deal?

taylor says:

im 11 and my mamma wants to read it first but WHAT IS THE BIG DEAL? come on!!!! its just a book! whats the worst that could happen? your daughters will turn into vampires? grown ups GET A LIFE! just let them read it first if they fell to uncormfirtable they WILL put it down! or skip that part!

Caroline Cullen says:

yes it is okay because im 9 and i read it

makayla says:

I have read all the books and think they're a lesson to learn about life, i mean if you dont let your kid read the books they'll be miserable trust me

twilight addict says:

ssoo?? i am 11 and i say who cares! i've read the series 4 times and i really think it's ok i guess..

Edward Anthony Masen Cullen says:

I AGREE WITH twilight fan! I KNEW WHAT 'IT' (THE 'STUFF' IN BREAKING DAWN) WAS WHEN I WAS LIKE EIGHT! NO JOKE!

Mary Alice Brandon Cullen says:

WTF IS THE BIG DEAL?! I KNOW ABOUT ALL THE 'STUFF' THAT'S IN IT BUT WHO FRIGGIN' CARES????? I DON'T!

Rosa says:

agree with twilight fan! Most people aged 11+ know about that stuff. I'm only talking 10+ plus here cause people aged 9 younger wont even be able to read the text itself and understand the meaning of the first book let alone the last! LOGIC

twilight fan says:

haha I new about that stuff beforeI was 12

TWImommie says:

Who really cares what anyone else has to say, it's your child, you make the decision yourself.

I am 21 years old and when I was in my teens I heard much more about the subject of sex from friends, teachers, my parents, then this book lets out. Honestly, if you let your child read the books and your worried about their "grasp on reality" then explain to them it is only a book, there are no vampires, as much as you would love for it to be true, it is not reality. And honestly when my child comes to that age years from now, I will explain this stuff to her. It's not like twilight is an adult novel. All I have to say is get over it, to all the uptight people on here, it's a book, and by the way, your kid is probably at her friends or library "studying" (code for i am reading twilight here because you won't let me at home" that's what they do....

and to you 11 to 15 year olds, you don't know what is or isn't appropriate for you to read, you can be mature for your age but it still makes no difference. sorry, you're votes do not count =) Try again later

miranda cullen says:

i have read a lot of YA books that go way farther in the sex department than this book even dreams about! there are some James paterson books that are YA and they describe everything that happens in the sex situations. so if ur kids can read that then i wouldnt worry about BD. There are books that are part of the school curriculum that have worse things in it. I would know bcus ive had to read worse things in order to pass my grade...which is 7th and that makes me 13 years old and i couldve handled this when i was 8 or 9 probably even 7 so i dont think anyone should be obsessing over the "maturity" in this book. Its fine, get over it!

The Book Should Have a Mature Content Warning!

jacqueline says:

I understand that young children seem to think they are ready for the "mature content" i.e the graphic sexual nature of the book, but they are not, it is innapropriate for young girls and if they have not had a proper sex talk then it will give them a wrong view on real life sex

khalen says:

oh please u were all little girls once and you all wanted instant gratification because it was what all the older cool girls were talking about.the reason all thease younger girls are getting prego and knowing about things they shouldnt is cause parents dont give a poop about what they wach or do just because maybe their 15 year old sister is going to see it or something.i dont even think kids so to speak should have a say in this forum because your not a 12 year old and dont curse little girls because that just proves us right.thats like saying oh man i cant go to senior prom because im a freshman what am i going to curse and scream till they let me in ?no because im smarter than that i mean cmon you are 10 years old and 11 your in what 5th grade for crying out your not even in middle school!!!!do your parents wach you!hell yea when i was in 5th grade i was mature for my age but that does not mean my moms going to let me read books about an18 year old girl that gets pregnant with a vampire and has to decide if she wants an abortion your not dealing with that stuff hopefully and i would think that stephanie meyer would say that is a no sorry.

Lexi says:

no! i am 12 myself and my mommy will not let me read eclipse OR breaking dawn! so i will say absalutley not!

Linda in Texas says:

I dont think its appropriate for a child but for a 12 year old yes. They are growing into young adults and need explanation from the parent. Parents if you dont talk to your child about sex and all of the bad stuff that can result from being sexually active someone else will step in and give your child advice. Guess what the ones who will be giving your child advice will be her friends. Lets be realistic not even children who are in High School know what a big responsiblity sex is. Let your child read it at age 12 and up and explain any questions remember its best they hear the truth from you.

Stephanie Meyer says:

A little risky for girls under 12 because of the mature scenes! May turn their healthy mind into a Dirty mind!

Anonymous says:

I believe Breaking Dawn should have a warning, however, those scenes are extremely important to the storyline. After all, the Twilight Series is romance, not horror.

Bellauren says:

Well... It just depends in maturity. I'm 13 and I was fine with it. But some of my friends were freaking out like it was a big deal that they had sex. But I agree that it should have some kind of 'warning' in the book like "for ages 13 and up".

Katiekid325990 says:

It has inappropriate content, that is too grown up for most children.

Jess says:

The twilight series was not intended to be read by children but I think that it would be okay for 10 years and up to read it because they aren't that bad. But they do have hard words and it is a complicated series. Another thing is it is mostly about romance and it has high school themes and would not interest children. If I had a child that young I wouldn't let them read the series because it would be mean to let them read three of the books and say no to the last one. (The last one is definitely not for children)

Marie Dove says:

I like I said before, it all depends on matureity. Some teen can't handle reading it or it might have a negitive inpacted. Always talk to them about it and always read it yourself if you're unsore.

 
view all 119 comments

 

What Does Stephenie Meyer Say About The Appropriateness Of Breaking Dawn And Young Readers? 

Stephenie would have been happy with a 15 and up label on Breaking Dawn...

Watch the Video Interview With Stephenie Meyer About the Appropriateness of Breaking Dawn and Young Readers.

 

Photobucket

If Breaking Dawn Were A Movie... 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

 

Photobucket

Want To Know What Others Are Saying About Breaking Dawn? 

 

Photobucket

Share Your Opinion Here! 

Loading poll. Please Wait...

 

Photobucket

New Moon Mania 

 

Photobucket

Bella's Birthday Party Dress 

A replica of the dress that Bella wears to her birthday party in the New Moon movie!

Twilight New Moon Bella Swan Green Birthday Dress

Twilight New Moon Bella Swan Green Birthday Dress

Look familiar, Twilighters? Get your own licensed replica of Bella's green taffeta dress that's accented with black flocked roses, a black velveteen waistband and black lace trim. Back zipper closure.

Available In Plus Sizes Too!
New Moon - Bella's Green Taffeta Dress

Ciao, Bella. Be mistaken for Edward's main squeeze when you rock this green taffeta dress, as worn by Bella in The Twilight Saga: New Moon. It features a pattern of flocked roses, velvet trim at the waist, and lace trim on the neck and sleeveless arms. Back zip entry.

 

Photobucket

 

Scene It? Twilight

Amazon Price: $46.99 (as of 11/25/2009)Buy Now

 

NECA Twilight "New Moon" Fleece (Jacob)

Amazon Price: $54.95 (as of 11/25/2009)Buy Now

 

Photobucket

 

Photobucket
Photobucket
Photobucket

submit
  • Reply
    Movies VS. Books Movies VS. Books Nov 17, 2009 @ 2:06 am
    I have a 7 year old boy & my friends little girl is 8, they are in love with the Twilight movie & we are very excited to see New Moon in a few days....I have read all 4 books myself & would not let my young child (boy or girl) read the books there is alot more detail then the movies. This series is amazing & definitly will let my son watch the movies (breaking dawn i will watch first & see exactly what they put in the movie). He loves Bella & Edward. Everyone makes a great point but if you explain it is a movie & that's it, it is no differnt from other stuff out there! Just a Mom's Thought!
  • Reply
    nikelover nikelover Nov 13, 2009 @ 6:08 pm
    Good stuff, however I think this movie is a bit inappropriate for kids. Older teens sure, but the youngers ones, it may be a bit much.
  • Reply
    amandascloset0 amandascloset0 Oct 17, 2009 @ 1:01 pm
    I personally feel the books and the movie are inappropriate for anyone under the age of 17. I think media with a upper teen to college age theme is being introduced to tweens far too often. So, that by the time these tweens are late teens/college age it takes blood, gore, etc.. hard core stuff to really be appealing to them.
  • Reply
    mitchking mitchking Sep 17, 2009 @ 11:47 am
    I personally feel that it is not appropriate for the age group that is seeing it. And for the age group it is appropriate for they do not want to see or read it since it is too tame for them. The vampire genre is a tough call when it comes to kids and the age for being exposed to it.
  • Reply
    Gabs Gabs Jul 23, 2009 @ 3:15 pm | in reply to twilight fan
    I am 13 and I started reading the books when i was 12. I was 13 when I read breaking dawn and eclipse and in 8th grade if that helps. Also my sister is 12 and is reading eclipse but I wont let her read Breaking dawn untill she is in 7th grade. If you think you are mature enough to read it and talk to your parents about I think you will be okay. :D
  • Reply
    BigGirlBlue BigGirlBlue Jun 14, 2009 @ 5:04 pm
    Great discussion. Personally, I consider young adult, which is what these books are rated at, to be 15 and up.
  • Reply
    AbbasAbedi AbbasAbedi Jun 13, 2009 @ 5:59 pm
    Important info. 5*
  • Reply
    twilight fan twilight fan Jun 4, 2009 @ 10:03 am
    well every one think twilight is so hash but i feel that if u r mature u can read it all right i know it has SEX in it but im 10 an i didn't go ooooooooooooooooooooo sex i went ok an like some of u said edward is the kind of guy who wants bella to be happy an he is not fourcing her to have sex at all so parents c if ur chide is matreu an u will find out don't worry ur teens just have to be matrue an 4 10 an up or under tooo so dont make a big deal sex is LIFE u have to let ur child explore it
  • Reply
    ftuley ftuley Jun 3, 2009 @ 7:44 pm
    Grat lens! 5 *'s
  • Reply
    RebeccaX0X0 RebeccaX0X0 Apr 22, 2009 @ 7:20 am
    Hello, I am fourteen years old and started reading the twilight saga about maybe two years ago.
    My personal opinion, The first book is probably mature enough for a nine year old to handle.
    The second book maybe a bit older, it all depends on maturity.
    Oh, and I hear all of these people talking about how innapropriate Eclipse and Breaking Dawn is.
    I just have to say Eclipse is NOT about sex at all, it has maybe a few pages of sex like, about maybe five pages of sex in it! Breaking Dawn, has more, and it gets more intense, but seriously, its not THAT bad, ive read books worse. I mean like, seriously. I think once you know about sex, and you like get your period and all that. You should be able to read Breaking Dawn, because you can understand it. My nine year old cousin is reading twilight, and she understands it, but shes like really mature.
    Some of you people are over-exxagerating, there is sex, but not that bad.
    Let people read what they want.
    Go Twilight!
  • Reply
    Temp_Girl Temp_Girl Apr 21, 2009 @ 2:47 am
    From a perspective of sexual relationships, the only thing that I think that the Twilight saga has going for it is that it encourages abstinence before marriage -- so in that way, the relationship between Bella and Edward is very sweet and nonthreatening. However, my concern is that the character of Bella is a throwback to everything that young women are encouraged to do and become. I the second book, for example, Bella wishes to eschew college and a career to be with Edward (and become immortal). Okay, so it's only a book (or a movie). but to my mind, this sends extremely dangerous signals to young women -- that education and providing a livelihood for oneself should come secondary to "landing" a boyfriend.

    Sorry if this is long-winded, BTW. I have a fascination with the whole Twilight cult phenomenon, and I have very mixed feelings about this particular angle. :)
  • Reply
    Ariana Ariana Apr 7, 2009 @ 10:10 pm
    I think that 10 is the right age. It also depends on the maturity. But I sure don't think that Twilight is inappropriate, especially when kids are exposed to more explicit things on the internet, T.V., and in school. In 4th grade we were talking about sex. Besides, so many people make such a big deal about Breaking Dawn and Eclipse, THERE ARE HARDLY ANY DETAILS ABOUT THE SEX IN BREAKING DAWN!
    For the people who think that Bella and Edward having sex is a bad influence for teenage girls, think about it some more. It could actually be a GOOD model. Most of the time, it is the men pressuring women to get in the bed, and a lot of times females feel pressured and do it when they are not ready. Edward shows that there are men out there that will wait to be married and not rush. The Twilight Series teaches that you should WAIT UNTIL MARRIAGE to have sex.
    Anyways, Twilight is not inappropriate in my view, because there are way worse things out there that your children are exposed to
  • Reply
    Treasures-By-Brenda Treasures-By-Brenda Apr 7, 2009 @ 2:01 pm
    Not personally a Twilight fan (only because I have not read or seen it), I can see huge value in what you have written here -- the personal review from the point of view of yourself and your 13 year old daughter is excellent and worthy of being blessed by a brand new SquidAngel!

    Brenda
  • Reply
    erica mcdonald erica mcdonald Mar 28, 2009 @ 10:36 pm | in reply to imnotaduck
    i realy wanty a twilight unbrella but mommy won't leat me :(
  • Reply
    erica mcdonald erica mcdonald Mar 28, 2009 @ 10:36 pm | in reply to imnotaduck
    i realy wanty a twilight unbrella but mommy won't leat me :(
  • Reply
    Mortira Mortira Mar 22, 2009 @ 3:25 pm
    When I worked in a bookstore, I had a hard time helping parents find books for their 13-16 year old daughters that weren't smutty. I usually directed them to the adult fiction books that I knew were more appropriate. Like you, I think it's important to know what our kids are reading. I'm sure many parents appreciate the heads up!
  • Reply
    MS WHO EVER CULLEN MS WHO EVER CULLEN Mar 11, 2009 @ 11:08 am
    I
    THINK
    ITS
    OK
    ANYONE
    WHO
    WANTS
    2
    READ
    IT
    !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Reply
    twilight fan twilight fan Mar 9, 2009 @ 8:32 am
    Im 10 and i am reading Breaking Dawn. Its the best book ever!.
  • Reply
    jchulew jchulew Feb 9, 2009 @ 12:08 pm
    Very interesting content and commentary. Personally I believe that parents need to research whatever books are in their child's hands and figure out for themselves if their child is mature enough for that book.
  • Reply
    bikki bikki Feb 1, 2009 @ 1:38 am
    Beautifully made page and great content!
  • Reply
    marissa marissa Jan 30, 2009 @ 8:52 pm
    im a ten years old in sixth grade in middle school at my school it is a poopular book in the middle school. I can handle the books but some children under 10 cant so A good advice is to read the books yourself. THEN let the children read it. Discus the book with them if they do not understand want is going on. i would start letting you children read it from 5grade for twilight and new moon and 6 grade and above read eclispe and breakind dawn (TIP breaking dawn contains some inapporate info) to me these books are wonderful
  • Reply
    iluvemt iluvemt Jan 26, 2009 @ 10:18 pm
    i think if ur mature enough for Twilight, at 11 at the least, you should read it. Twiligtfanforever I don't know what ur talking about. If your 10, you really shouldn't read them. The 1 and 2 books are totally clean, but the 3 and 4 books are the only questionable. Also twilightfanforever i don't know if you noticed but the series is called TEEN. and last time i checked a 10 year old is NOT a teen. hey roro plz shut up. thts like the last thing we need, poisning kids minds even more, ya great. :)
  • Reply
    twilight fan twilight fan Jan 19, 2009 @ 12:36 pm
    im 11 and read the first 2 books .there is a mixed review on what age you should be 2 read next books im so confussed plz help!! im a great reader and very mature for my age !

    p.s. first 2 books rock
  • Reply
    SaraMu SaraMu Jan 1, 2009 @ 12:08 pm
    Love your polka dots. And, I appreciate you taking the time to talk about this relevant topic.
  • Reply
    Chelsea Chelsea Dec 26, 2008 @ 2:37 pm
    I'm 12 and seriously if you can't handle Twilight at 10-12 yrs. old you are seriously immature. The series does have that kind of stuff in it but WHAT THE HECK? It's just romance. If your child does not know what sex is at that age you need to have a long and very important talk because those classes might be coming soon for them (mine were last yr in 5th grade :] )
  • Load More

by enslavedbyfaeries





online counter


125x125 - New Moon Exclusive Poster and Tee - Hott



125x125- Twilight Party Supplies



Official New Moon Fan Portal - Shop Now!


The Twilight Saga: New Moon Deluxe Party Pack


New Moon Tickets on Sale Now




Are the Twilight book and movies appropriate for kids and younger girls? (more)

enslavedbyfaeries Recommends...

Create a Lens!