Would you eat meat if you had to slaughter the animals yourself?

Ranked #17,222 in Food & Cooking, #303,043 overall

How Hungry Are You?

If your meat did not come prepackaged in clean, shiny plastic wrap and you had to actually kill the animals yourself, would you still eat meat?

In my opinion, it is easy to be blind to the horrors that animals raised for food endure when you buy your meat pre-packaged at the grocery store. The truth is that most animals raised for food do not live in wide open pastures. They are born, raised and killed in factories. It makes me wonder if people actually had to face the animals before their death if they would still have such an appetite for meat.
Loading poll. Please Wait...

Would you eat meat if you had to kill the animals yourself?

Loading Fetching blurbs now... please stand by

No

Blade says:

The only meat I will ever eat again is HUMANS if they are ever on the menu. Animals are incredible creatures and have every right to life, unlike all the retards we are forced to live with.

Dave says:

No way

pinkrenegade says:

No I could never do it, I would make them all my pets

Me says:

I am not sure - it depends if it was short term or long term. Short term = No, long term = I don't know. I would find it hard not to develop compassion for them, because they bond and have emotions. As for the slaughter process, I think I would have to shoot them if I could bring myself to do it. However, if somebody said, shoot your dog for meat, there is no way I could do it. Being sane at the moment, I would never do it - I would starve to death. I know that the animals suffer, yet I still eat the meat. There must be something wrong with me here :( I know it is wrong, but I still do it! What is wrong with me?!?!

alana says:

definatly not!

Yes

Jo says:

I have killed and eaten various animals. It is very satisfying to know how the animal has lived and that you gave it the best possible while it was alive. One must remember, after all, that if we did not eat meat, millions if animals would not be here at all and the countryside would be a very different place. I could never contemplate being a veggie and I am grateful to be able to feed my baby and toddler meat protein.

mrdoobie.com says:

I don't think I would eat meat as much as I do, though I never craved meat, I have enjoyed it. If I had to kill the animal myself, I could do it. Though I believe the consumption of the meat would be more appreciated. I would probably honor the animals life, as some tribal natives do. The animal would be loved... in a calming place.... held and brought to peace and calm relaxation before I would sedate it... and while it was unconscious, I would make certain the death went quickly... then I would take time while the animal was dying to honor it's life and transition... spiritually.. as well as the nutrition it would be giving my life. I would make certain the meat was prepared with care... and the meals would be something to remember... each preceded by another vocalized appreciation of the animals life and sacrifice. I do not kill the animals that I consume now... but I do take a moment before eating to silently appreciate the animals life (as not to bring guilt feelings upon others around me) and only talk about the idea with those who seem very caring, intelligent, but misguided and open to different ideas. When my mate burns the chicken and goes to throw it out... I try to find good in the meal and salvage what I can... and can't deny feeling more than simply just wasted meat.

BiggBenn says:

I can see both sides of the argument, but I absolutely would eat an animal if I had to kill it myself. Humans are omnivores, but animal protein is an absolutely needed part of our diet. It cannot be synthesized and the essential amino acids are needed for proper nutrition and body function. In my view, people that purposefully omit meat or animal products from their diets are just transferring the "pain and suffering" supposedly caused to animals that are killed or used as a food source onto themselves.

deathbringer666 says:

i agree on both sides of the argument i belive in the balance of pray and pedetor u only need to chek my name but i love a nimals so i would NEVER eat one of those poor animals in the factoryis i guess quite a few people agree.

Hope says:

I'm a vegetarian to a point, I hate the factory slaughter,but I also believe in the balance of life of prey and predator.Most factories do not kill humanly, many FDA workers have been known to let slaughter houses with cruel conditions slip by because they know workers or other reasons. I only eat meat if i know how the animal was killed.For example when I go fishing or my dad goes hunting since I know he kills the animals more humanely than any factory. I still stay on a mostly vegetarian diet though

 
view all 31 comments

In the News...

Chipotle Sells Twisted Image of Animal Agriculture
The video contrasts a dismal "factory farm" with cheerful, Chipotle-approved grasslands where pigs run free. In an effort to sell their products, Chipotle misrepresents the real conditions and science behind large scale food production.
Chipotle's factory farming ad steals Grammys spotlight
It's an indictment of what many consider a dark side to the meat industry here in America: factory farming. While people may dream of animals roaming free before being taken to slaughterhouses, in reality, most meat comes from animals held in cramped ...
Chipotle's Grammy Ad: Great Farming Practices, Or Just Great Filmmaking?
Produced last year, it's titled "Back to the Start" and features a roly-poly animated farmer who gradually shifts his adorable livestock from their bucolic pasture to a factory farm. Then, dismayed with the results of the industrialized system, ...
Chipotle's Grammy Upstaging Ad Scores Major Points For Their Brand Identity
Chipotle's wildly popular animated commercial, which uses cute puppets to portray the dark side of factory farming, and emphasizes the food chains commitment to sustainable and environmentally friendly farming practices, has made huge waves in the ...

Highly Recommended DVD's

Fast Food Nation

Amazon Price: $5.92 (as of 02/18/2012)Buy Now

Inspired by the incendiary New York Times bestseller that exposed the hidden facts behind America's fast food industry Fast Food Nation combines an all-star ensemble cast lead by Greg Kinnear Wilmer Valderrama and Avril Lavigne with riveting interlocked human stories to serve up "a firecracker of a movie that jumps off the screen" (Rolling Stone). When a marketing executive (Kinnear) for the Mickey's burger chain is told there's a nasty secret ingredient in his latest culinary creation "The Big One" he heads for the ranches and slaughterhouses of Colorado to investigate...but discovers the truth a bit difficult to swallow.Episodes-Bonus Features:Widescreen FeatureCommentary with Director Richard Linklater and Writer Eric SchlosserManufacturing Fast Food Nation FeaturetteThe Meatrix Flash Animation ShortThe Meatrix II Flash Animation ShortThe Meatrix II 1/2 Flash Animation ShortThe Backwards Hamburger Flash Animation ShortPhoto GallerySystem Requirements:Running Time: 113 minsFormat: DVD MOVIE Genre: DRAMA Rating: R UPC: 024543418689 Manufacturer No: 2241868

EARTHLINGS

Amazon Price: $16.45 (as of 02/18/2012)Buy Now

Narrated by Academy Award nominee Joaquin Phoenix (WALK THE LINE, GLADIATOR), EARTHLINGS is a feature-length documentary about humankind's absolute economic dependence on animals raised as pets, food, clothing, entertainment and for scientific research. Using hidden cameras and never-before-seen footage, EARTHLINGS chronicles the day-to-day practices at some of the largest industries in the world, all of which rely entirely on animals for profit. Powerful, informative and thought-provoking, EARTHLINGS is by far the most comprehensive documentary ever produced on the correlation between nature, animals and human economic interests.

More Information About Factory Farming

The End of Factory Farming
The brutality of factory farming, and its effects on the inner life of humanity.

Vegetarian Cooking & Recipes

Vegetarian Meatloaf
Well, OK, technically it's not 'meat'loaf, but anyway you make it it's hearty satisfying, savory and in a loaf. There are even some recipes that are made with all of the same ingredients as traditional meatloaf with just a protein exchange.
Vegetarian Comfort Food Recipes
Over the years I realized that I didn't have to give up on most comfort foods; I just had to find alternatives. That said, these recipes do not include meat substitutes like soy (tofu) or TVP. They are, however, easy to make, totally satisfying and great meals to serve to your meat eating friends.
Vegetarian BBQ
It's summertime, the official start of grilling season! In addition to providing the smoky flavor that emanates from the coals, grilling caramelizes the natural sugars in the vegetables and makes them taste extra sweet.
Vegetarian Chili
Tired of all the vegetarian chili recipes saying things like 'light, low fat, and colorful?' That's not what chili is about; It's about comfort food and having something warm to eat with your freshly baked cornbread on a cold day. This chili is spicy, 'meaty' and delicious.
Vegetarian Weight Loss Plan
Amy's Kitchen is the nation's top-selling brand of natural and organic convenience foods and is celebrating it's 20th anniversary.Many customers have said that they have lost weight eating Amy's, either on their own or with a well-known weight plan such as E-Diets, Good Housekeeping, Jorge Cruise...
Vegan Egg Substitutes- Compassionate And Healthy Alternatives To Eggs
I'm vegan and I love love love baking, but just about every baking recipe requires eggs-and I don't eat eggs! I choose not to eat eggs because they are not necessary for human health and survival, plus the chickens live in horrendous conditions, even the 'free range' chickens producing...

Photobucket

submit
  • Reply
    Yourshowman Oct 5, 2010 @ 10:39 am | delete
    I am a pure vegetarian and i would never eat meat..
  • Reply
    Treasures-By-Brenda Jun 2, 2009 @ 7:57 pm | delete
    Interesting subject, thanks for making me think about it. Your Monkeybrains lens is blessed by Brenda.
  • Reply
    josefgraf Sep 26, 2008 @ 12:15 pm | delete
    If those who consume mass meat products could witness either a) the conditions 95% of the animals in the factory farm industry have to endure, or b) the loss that is accruing in humanity's inner life due to this animal abuse - the industry would grind to a halt overnight. Surely the human race cannot be as diabolical as its relationship with the animal kingdom suggests.
    - the Earth Vision project, 2008

    For further links and resources on this issue visit the Earth Vision site at www.evsite.net

    Click on: The End of Factory Farming
    Or go here:
    http://www.evbooks.net/earth_vision_029.htm

    The specific article:

    The End of Factory Farming - the ecological resonance between the animal holocaust and our inner life

    Josef
  • Reply
    SunGal Aug 2, 2008 @ 11:41 pm | delete
    My mom was raised on a farm and one of her chores was to kill and pluck the chickens. But they took good care of their animals and when it was time, they killed them humanely. If I had to do it to feed my family I would. I don't eat much meat, it has mostly lost its appeal for me, but if I do, I buy free range.
  • Reply
    EverythingMouse Jul 13, 2008 @ 3:05 pm | delete
    I think this is a very interesting question and I think for the majority surely the answer is no. Perhaps if people realized exactly how meat is processed and animals are treated they may think twice about eating it - and putting pressure on the food industry to change. I have been a vegetarian since I was 7 years old so for me the answer is definitely no!
  • Load More
Loading
Meatrix Video Credits:
TheOfficialMeatrix

Loading

Loading

Loading

by

enslavedbyfaeries

Who knew that writing silly pages about sparkly vampires and guyliner would lead to a full-time, work-at-home job? I certainly had no idea that I would... more »

Feeling creative? Create a Lens!