The Empires and Enclaves of Europe
Ranked #9,598 in Culture & Society, #193,323 overall | Donates to International Rescue Committee, FIV Cat Rescue
Coping with the Legacy of Conquest
Enclaves and Exclaves
Enclave
(Figure 1)
Exclave
(Figure 2)
Why are enclaves and exclaves important?
Our news services, distracted by the need to "entertain," do us little service either, by failing to provide this necessary background. Even the BBC and CNN don't always get into the depth that is needed for real understanding.
Many contemporary geopolitical problems stem from or are at least heavily shaped, by legacies of empire that cannot be expressed satisfactorily in our modern system of nation-states, especially the problems of enclaves and exclaves (see above).
As to the map of Azerbaijan, I love the image of a bird flying over the Caucasus with Baku, the beak, jutting out into the Caspian sea. But the enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh is not even indicated on the map. The detached tail feather is the Azerbaijani exclave of Naxcivan.
Naxcivan was created when Stalin (a Georgian) attached "Russian Armenia" to Armenia "proper", detaching the Azeri population west of this area from Azerbaijan "proper" - not a problem when both Armenians and Azeris are "subjects" of Ottoman Turkey or Stalinist Russia. A perpetual causus belli when both countries are independent.
Please 'Listen': Global Voices
- Global Voices Online
- Global Voices aggregates, curates, and amplifies the global conversation online - shining light on places and people other media often ignore.
The 3:00 AM Call
A Focus on Empires, Enclaves and Exclaves
But from time to time, one or other of these city-states or families/tribes would conquer its neighbors, then their neighbors, and so on. All of the people(s) in an area would come under the domination of a single Emperor. More often than not, the Empire would disintegrate through family squabbling about who gets the throne on on the death of the Emperor, or by family decay within four generations . When that empire declined, or was defeated, a patchwork quilt of different peoples was left behind.
Sometimes, this led to a cosmopolitan successor society where the different peoples came together successfully. But just as often, the solution of one culture to resolve "the problem of ethnicities" has been 'ethnic cleansing' or forced external or internal migration.
.png)
[Europe according to a widely accepted definition: geographic Europe in green, and cultural Europe in dark blue (Asian parts of European states in light blue). Even this map under-reports the Eastern distribution of European influence and culture, and the effects of Stalin's Russification policies.
Just think about the Jewish Autonomous Republic, bordering China in the Far East, or the European character of Harbin, capital of the Province of Helongjiang, People's Republic of China, where Russian workers began the building of the Chinese Eastern Railway.]
This set of cascading lenses concentrates on three "legacies of empire" - the Ottoman Empire, especially its effect on the Balkans, the Caucasus, and the Levant; the Austro-Hungarian Empire and its legacy for Central Europe; the Soviet Union and its legacy in the Baltic; Each of these will be coupled with consideration of Russia's current policies and military strategies - thus Russia in the Balkans; Russia in the Baltic; and Russia in the Caucasus.
There are also connected lenses that will explore displacements and diasporas; the possibility and roles of international and supranational legal systems; and the naval strategy dimension of current crises between Russia and the West.
The module takes an apparently loose view of the Eastern boundary of "Europe" based in fact on the Russian definition that the five westernmost Federal Districts of Russia are all in Europe, because they are west of the Urals. That, together with Russia's past southern expansion, takes us at least as far east as the Caspian Sea. Only 3% of Turkey's land mass is actually in Europe by geographical definition, but politically, it defines itself as being wholly in Europe. Intellectually,culturally, it is in bothEurope and Asia. Armenia, Georgia, and Azerbaijan are also European countries.
All this will be from an Anglo-American perspective. That's what I know. I am by no means an expert but I will try to provide useful pointers to at least some of the underlying factors that should be taken into account when considering contemporary crises, when the phone rings at 3 a.m. Washington time, "Why this now?"
The Role of THIS Lens
There's not much cultural or political content at this level, mainly pointers to the subsidiary lenses. However, there are a number of entries about tools, perspectives, and learning opportunities.
This lens is not specifically aimed at any audience. I hope it will be useful for college and high school teachers; interested adults; and all those news freaks out there.
From Empire to Nationhood
- KCL: ISS - Archives - Empire to Nationhood exhibition
- Online exhibition concerning the
aftermath of World War Two for Britain and nations of its former empire
L'Europe des Patries and TheTreaty of Lisbon
Fair and Balanced Reporting?
I grew up in north west England, in the county of Lancaster. The county of Yorkshire, just the other side of the Pennine range, was the old enemy. (See Shakespeare's 'Richard III' for details.) We referred, every year, to the annual cricket match, as "the War of the Roses." Genuine natives of each county, in those pre-TV days, spoke almost mutually unintelligible versions of English. But we had no doubt we were all part of England, Britain, and the Commonwealth of Nations (the re-working of the British Empire),
On the other hand, I'm from a Welsh family, went to a bilingual college in Wales, and my nieces and great nephews are all products of the Welsh-language education system. I've campaigned for greater autonomy for Wales. I think an independent Wales would be viable within Europe, but I'm happy with the current arrangement (a Welsh Assembly within the United Kingdom).
Basically, I advocate federal structures which would accommodate local and regional self-expression, as an alternative to full independence and "Balkanization." My shorthand label to describe this policy is a mis-re-appropriation of the phrase "Europe des Patries" - de Gaulle meant by this, a European Community that was a confederation where the constituent countries retained more sovereignty than states do in the US system. That's the one thing the founding fathers didn't take over from the Iroquios Confederacy.I'm using it here to describe a (con)federal structure which would allow freedom for 'self-determination' across nation/state boundaries. This would be an answer to the Basque 'problem' and maybe a better answer for Scotland and Wales.
I now live in the US which, I guess, reinforces my Anglo-American perspective on the issues discussed "below."
Who might benefit from a new kind of Europe des Patries?
The Basque
The Flemish and The Walloons
The Welsh
Academic Perspectives
Language Learning

I'm British, I live in the USA. I travel quite a lot and have had a few stints of working for short periods (6 weeks - 3 months) in countries where English is not the national language. In every case, I could manage in English: I speak well four varieties of English - Midwestern White American, East Coast Australian, and British in both its Lancashire and Queen's Received (poor and posh) dialects but really no other languages with any degree of fluency.
In some ways this is the legacy of colonialism and empire, next to slavery, that we should be most ashamed of. We don't bother to learn other people's languages because they had/have to learn ours. This must change. Politics aside, the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis tells us that every distinct language has a core set of concepts which are lost or diminished in translation. It isn't just the many Inuktitut words for snow, or different people seeing different values in the color circle, it includes words like vendetta or jihad which are never translated fully So we should really, really try to improve our linguistic skills. My browser has an auto-translate plug-in, I try to not let it make me lazy but use it to check out that web sites I'm looking at are reasonably in the ball-park of what they pretend to be. All that being said, I will include links to relevant non-English-language sites with a clear conscience. Maybe even some Fench ones.
Legacies of Empire
Other Perspectives
The Great Experiment: The Story of Ancient Empires, Modern States, and the Quest for a Global Nation
Amazon Price: $2.75 (as of 02/15/2012)![]()
If you are at all interested in the idea underlying the Empires and Enclaves series of lenses - that the end of empires has left behind nation-states fatally flawed and incompetent at meeting the needs of their encapsulated minorities - this book is a necessity!
Current Crises
Current Flashpoints
Connections
Group and Index Lenses
A Final Thought....
Feedback
-
Reply
-
AddaptAbilities
Aug 10, 2011 @ 5:09 pm | delete
- Exceedingly *blessed*. This is one of the best lenses I've ever read (from my American bias, anyway :). You've taken a topic that seems dry and obscure, zeroed in on the salient points, and explained why it's actually vital to understanding anything that happens in the world. I studied African politics in college, so I know all too well the tragic legacies of colonial borders. Well done!
-
The Wordle for this lens
(click to enlarge)
Wordle was Created by http://wordle.net/ For copyright information about Wordle, and other material in this cascade of lenses, please see:
Contents of This Lens
- Enclaves and Exclaves
- Enclave
- Exclave
- Please 'Listen': Global Voices
- The 3:00 AM Call
- A Focus on Empires, Enclaves and Exclaves
- The International Rescue Comittee
- The Role of THIS Lens
- From Empire to Nationhood
- L'Europe des Patries and TheTreaty of Lisbon
- Academic Perspectives
- Language Learning
- Legacies of Empire
- Other Perspectives
- Current Crises
- Connections
- Group and Index Lenses
- A Final Thought....
- Feedback
- The Wordle for this lens
- About Me
About Me
by madoc
You may have noticed it can be quite confusing to be Tony Scott. There are so many of us. And, just maybe, most of us are left-handed...
Take the f...
more »
- 215 featured lenses
- Winner of 12 trophies!
- Top lens » Agrarian Reform: The Philippines
Explore related pages
- Russia and the Post-Soviet States Russia and the Post-Soviet States
- The Ottoman Empire The Ottoman Empire
- The Austro-Hungarian Empire and its Legacy The Austro-Hungarian Empire and its Legacy
- Thirteen Days in October: The Cuban Missile Crisis Thirteen Days in October: The Cuban Missile Crisis
- Timbuktu : Where in the World? Timbuktu : Where in the World?
- The Candy Bombers and the Berlin Airlift The Candy Bombers and the Berlin Airlift